Forum: DCForumID88
Thread Number: 178
[ Go back to previous page ]
Original Message
"What would Simon have said?"
Posted by jpl68 on 09-14-05 at 08:16 AM
After watching Tuesday's performances, several thoughts ran through my head:(1) The first thought was, wow, I think Garry has taken up smoking crack. What did he say, something along the lines of thank you Marty for that wonderful interpretation of Creep (apparenlty Marty's voice magically and dramatically deteriorated from the time it came out of his mouth live to when it was filterd through the television set to my ears). I had to replay what he said to Mig 3 times because I thought I was hearing things, . . . something along the lines of with that performance I don't see you being in the bottom three. Anyhow, I digress.
(2) The second thought was I wondered what Simon Cowell's comments would have been to each performer. Here is my take:
Suzie: Suzie, . . . at least you looked great.
J.D.: I think with that performance, you have won this competition.
Marty: Its unfortunate for you Marty that you had to follow J.D. I thought your performance was OooKay, but it was not your best performance and I thought your version of Trees last week was better. The problem Marty is that Ok simply doesn't cut it at this stage of the competition.
Mig: So what! No, I mean really, Kiss from a Rose was nice. I personally thought Paint it Black was a mess, but regardless, . . . so what.
Table of contents
- Fun idea!,weltek, 09:58 AM, 09-14-05
- RE: Fun idea!,jpl68, 10:16 AM, 09-14-05
- RE: What would Simon have said?,Tahj, 11:41 AM, 09-14-05
- RE: What would Simon have said?,trigirl, 12:06 PM, 09-14-05
Messages in this discussion
"Fun idea!"
Posted by weltek on 09-14-05 at 09:58 AM
Suzie: I'm frankly surprised the crowd loved that. I thought it was an absolute disaster.J.D.: If it were up to me, I'd give you the job right now.
Marty: I thought your vocals were trecherous, but you have that "it" factor that's popular right now. You don't have the best voice of this competition, but you pulled it off.
Mig: I'm going to disagree with Paula & Randy. That was just okay for me. *shrug*
"RE: Fun idea!"
Posted by jpl68 on 09-14-05 at 10:16 AM
Bravo, and I love the Paula and Randy reference! As Simon would say, . . . well done!
"RE: What would Simon have said?"
Posted by Tahj on 09-14-05 at 11:41 AM
Simon: I hate rock and roll, especially when it's screechy and depressing. I can't tell who was good and who wasn't. I'm all about fluffy pop. It makes my man boobs tingle.
Moves courtesy of Syren
"RE: What would Simon have said?"
Posted by trigirl on 09-14-05 at 12:06 PM
Excuse me Brooke, but only I am allowed to wear children's sized clothing on this show.
