URL: http://community.realitytvworld.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/rtvw2/community/dcboard.cgi
Forum: DCForumID87
Thread Number: 94
[ Go back to previous page ]
Original Message
"Jonathan & Gizelle"
Posted by bole on 01-22-06 at 10:43 PM
i thought they were 100% better than master p. as a side note, the p should stand for "p"athetic dancer or "p"issy attitude. i thought they were even better than george hamilton. something is wrong with the voting system or the voters are just not watching the whole show. stop voting the better dancers off!
Table of contents
Messages in this discussion
"RE: Jonathan & Gizelle"
Posted by DooWahDitty on 01-22-06 at 11:16 PM
As for Jonathan and Giselle -- since that is the title of the thread, and P is being discussed elsewhere, we don't want this thread locked, though it IS a dead subject since they got booted -- I do believe she is a great dancer, a really fine dancer, and looked very elegant and relaxed.

I believe the judges dissed her for no good reason other than to make it look authentic when coughcough*someone-else*coughcough got to stay. I really enjoyed watching their stint Fri. night (forgot to watch Thurs.)


syg by Cyg

"RE: Jonathan & Gizelle"
Posted by Queene1979 on 01-23-06 at 09:47 AM
I read on some message board that people are voting for Master P. just to mess with the show and the judges.
"RE: Jonathan & Gizelle"
Posted by irishrose on 01-23-06 at 10:19 AM
I agree. I think the Judges were a-lot harder on Jonathan and Giselle then on some of the other dancers. I thought they danced a beautiful tango and Deserved to stay. But alas that was not in the cards. I think Giselle was correct when she was saying that because she was in broadcast news that she did not have the fan base that some of the others have (we all know who that is) so they needed big judges scores to stay. They just did not have the people behind them to keep them there.
"RE: Jonathan & Gizelle"
Posted by prosecutor on 01-24-06 at 02:28 PM
Why was Gizelle even on the show she is no "star" how many of you even heard of her. At least the others are known at least to me. I never heard of her before. So better her than you know who heh heh.
"RE: Jonathan & Gizelle"
Posted by Fishercat on 01-25-06 at 03:11 PM
From what I've learned over the years, it isn't usually about pure talent. Sure, she's a better dancer than Master P and likely George. However, it wasn't really entertaining. At this point, I think Master P is spite voting, but George actually tries to mix it up and entertain more in his dances. He is different. And if I have a choice at this point, let me keep the entertaining but worse dancer over the technically better but snooze-worthy performance. She was likely the 4th rated female remaining (Tia and Stacy I'd definitely put above, and this week, I liked Fishlips Lisa Rinna better), and simply not entertaining.

It's the same logic with me preferring to keep a Jon Peter Lewis (American Idol) a George Hamilton (DwtS) or even a Crazy Dave (AI Auditions) over a Leah Labelle (AI), a Giselle Fernandez (DwtS), or a fringe "going to Hollywood" singer. If they aren't going to win or make it to F3 or F4 anyway, may as well keep the comic relief around. Sure, I want a Stacy/Drew to win this, I want the best dancer to win, but it's not usually about who's best until the very end.

Bob Factoid: The fishercat is the only creature known to have gone completely insane chasing its own tail.