please please please i hope phil gets sent packing tonight!

don't let him be on the american idol tour...its all he wants and he makes me sick...he is all full of himself when he finishes his song ...but as soon as he gets a bad word from simon

out comes the pouting....close those big ugly eyes and leave! oh and take the crying little girl with you.(i think she was a plant)
mollytv
anyone with me on this one?

• RE: PHIL....yuck!,LisaPles, 09:55 AM, 03-21-07
  • RE: PHIL....yuck!,bob_chester, 04:37 PM, 03-27-07
    • RE: PHIL....yuck!,bob_chester, 10:40 AM, 03-28-07
• RE: PHIL....yuck!,zipperhead, 10:05 AM, 03-21-07
• RE: PHIL....yuck!,Wasabi, 12:19 PM, 03-21-07
• RE: PHIL....yuck!,selah, 12:40 PM, 03-21-07
• RE: PHIL....yuck!,agman, 02:43 PM, 03-21-07
  • RE: PHIL....yuck!,prosecutor, 10:58 AM, 03-22-07
    • RE: PHIL....yuck!,Alysa, 00:32 AM, 04-15-07
      • RE: PHIL....yuck!,agman, 08:09 PM, 04-18-07
        • RE: PHIL....yuck!,curveball, 04:43 PM, 04-19-07
          • RE: PHIL....yuck!,agman, 09:38 PM, 04-19-07
• RE: PHIL....yuck!,joannie, 03:09 PM, 03-22-07
• RE: PHIL....yuck!,agman, 06:58 PM, 04-20-07
• RE: PHIL....yuck!,MollyTV, 11:29 PM, 05-02-07
  • RE: PHIL....yuck!,zipperhead, 11:37 AM, 05-03-07

I'm with you. I don't even evaluate his singing because I can't get past his shiny bald head. He looks creepy!

p.s. - Somebody needs to give the crying girl some Prozac!

Hey easy on the bld stuff. lol I am bald and so is my dad.This guy is just unerving. I think it is the smile or something like that but then again it might be the shape of his head and ears.....
I wish we could vote of him, Chris R. and Haley tonight. But alas we can only vote of one.
Darn
lol
Then we can get Rid of Sanjaya . lol

I am going to have to say I really liked Phils Preformance last night. It was a difficult song last night and he did one of the best preformances of the night.

I actually liked Phil last night and I don't think the judges gave him enough credit for improving his performance. In fact, I think it was pretty obvious that they are not going to be happy with him no matter what he does and they want him gone.

Not am I only with you, I can't understand what he is doing at this stage of the competition anyway. The only reason he made it through first audition was because he missed the birth of his daughter and it was a good story. That's where it should have ended for him. There is not a single aspect of his voice/personality/stage presence that I enjoy.

in agreement that this girl was a plant as I posted in the other thread about the crying girl..

as for Phil, I wonder if we would feel the same if he had hair? he is very strange looking without it.. some people should just have hair, and Phil is definitely one of them.

I didn't care for him last night, that's for sure and would be happy if he left..

LAST EDITED ON 03-30-07 AT 10:42 PM (EST)

Couldn't agree more. I even picked him on a different post to get sent packing. I don't know why he thinks he's so great. I actually think Sanjaya did better than he did,and that hurts to say!!!!!I finally put my finger on the other thing that gives me the creeps about Phil. He looks like Uncle Fester from the adams family. That guy I always thought was weird. agman

Phil is surviving because his marine buddies are loyal to him, so he will probably outlast a lot of other singers who are way more deserving.

my gosh, his voice is absolutely DEAD.

>my gosh, his voice is absolutely
>DEAD.
But you have to admit, he was much better last night than he has been all season. As Randy would say, maybe country is his thaaaaangggg dog!

A snidget original

I don't think he knows what his thing is. I think he just went with Randy on that...

I like country, I like Carrie, Kelly P, and even Josh G., but I don't see Phil opening for Kenny or Keith any time soon.

LAST EDITED ON 04-19-07 AT 10:33 PM (EST)

>I don't think he knows what
>his thing is.

I never said I was now his biggest fan. I just stated that imo he's done better with country than anything else. That does not mean he's the next Garth Brooks. Sorry I wasn't a bit morre clear. I think I was still in shock because he surprised me.

Gone, but certainly not forgotten