I guess all your negativity is breathing new life into Scott,Now
understand this the country has spoken Scott and Anthony are safe this week, so let this be a lesson instead of tearing someone down build up the one you believe in. Constantine will be alright he doesn't know it yet he's bigger than American Idol.
Look for his album before the year is out. Scott you have just showed the nay sayers what it is really all about, sing it with your heart own it, you big sexy you.

NO discussion of tonight's results outside of the thread on the General Discussion forum until after midnight.

And if you don't want to read basher posts, then this isn't the place for you. Unlike other forums, we allow posters to express both positive and negative opinions of reality show contestants - and you have no right to tell them not to. Please note the message at the top of each forum page, as well as our community guidelines, and abide by them.

Look, we welcome new posters here, but what part of "do not post results before midnight on this forum" did you think didn't apply to you? As a moderator, I'm telling you - do not post about tonight's show on this thread again until, after midnight. And read the community guidelines, please.

Scott, if the average Joe from the Midwest is a no-class weinie, then Average Joe, you are! Why didn't eou and the other weinie takB a clue from Big time classie bo? Wen asked to stand with the group he thought he belonged in, Bo stood in the middle. You and Constanweinie when asked the asked question, went and stood next to the 'winners', leaving Anthony and Vonzell to feel like 'losers'. That showed a compete lack of class. Even worse, when your weinie buddie was voted off, you grinned bigger than I've ever seen you grin. It was tactless as well as classless. Tacky. Tacky. Tacky. NO CLASS WEINIE-SCOTT!

Obviously there are a lot of Scott lovers out there. It does make for interesting tv.

Handcrafted by RollDdice

Eh, Scott blows. He sounds atrocious and is so not 'average Joe' in my book. People, get a clue...STOP voting for the guy. Please!

I don't want to end up with another Rueben. His CD's just sat on the shelves. Anybody else left is loads better than Scott.

As much as I have poked fun at Scott, I must admit I am glad that America voted against Simon's thoughts on this one. His performance was not horrible, and perhaps an average joe is what we need to be an idol.

Scott is...

only an above average singer.
unlikeable.
an angry thug who beats his "wife" (actually he doesn't even have the cojones to marry the mother of his child).
does NOT belong on this stage any more.

It is LUDICROUS that he is still in this competition. If Scott wins he will sell even fewer albums than Fantasia (proving once again that character DOES count) and may toll the doom of this show.

At least Red was a nice guy who couldn't sing. Scott is an unlikeable thug who can't sing.

I agree with PRE. (Hey, stop laughing people, the world is full of unexplained mysteries)

Scott sucks. And, from what I hear, he also smells.

I was hoping the pictures of Scott's son would lose him votes from the Christian Average Joe Midwest. Inter-racial relationship and all that.

But I guess instead they figured his Baby-momma prolly deserved the ass-kicking he gave her, what with being uppity enough to date a white guy.

Or maybe all those "Christian Average Joe Midwest, Inter-racial relationship" stereotypes are played out.

He definitely smells. I'm sticking to my guns with the FABAN acronym

Spidey, I am not sure if your post was over-the-top demented race-baiting or sly tongue-in-cheek. Which one?

Then let the mods handle it and don't respond on your own. That's how threads get off-topic.

Discussing racial issues is not against the guidelines, and commenting on a perceived double-standard isn't either. And it's a lot less provocative than a number of the discussions currently going on in other forums.

Bebo's right, but just to clarify I wasn't trying to offend anyone, except maybe Scott voters. And even then just a little because they didn't sink as low as I thought they would.

I guess I was still a little sore about Constantine getting the boot while this ignoramus continues.

And to be honest, when I saw his child the thought did cross my mind that he might lose votes over it. And despite the fact that I despise watching him perform, I was saddened by that thought.

It is a sad double standard - a female contestant with an out of wedlock child is criticized, while a male contestant with a child out of wedlock is held up as a loving father who loves his baby.

Not by me - but it warn't no baby or lack of responsibility/integrity/charisma that cost Scott my vote.

Just the fact that this is a singing competition.

If Scott doesn't win, take comfort in the fact that he'll always have work as long as Larry the Cable Guy needs an opening act.

Bow before the evil queen
How dare you insects come after ME!