• RE: AI 11 Top 9 Rankings,zazzy, 10:20 AM, 03-29-12
  • RE: AI 11 Top 9 Rankings,zazzy, 11:15 AM, 03-29-12
  • RE: AI 11 Top 9 Rankings,csnumber23, 04:22 PM, 03-29-12
• RE: AI 11 Top 9 Rankings,emydi, 11:11 AM, 03-29-12
• RE: AI 11 Top 9 Rankings,csnumber23, 04:19 PM, 03-29-12
• RE: AI 11 Top 9 Rankings,frodis, 04:42 PM, 03-29-12

I was waiting for someone to do the rankings thread! ;)

Mods should close mine--here's what I wrote:

----------------

Very good night overall. Judges did the standing O way too many times...but overall an entertaining night. Really liked the Elise/P2/Colton trio, too.

Tied for first:

1. Elise -- more of this type of performance, please!

1. Joshua -- I wish you were not so hard on yourself and could enjoy the competition more. You look so unhappy for someone so, so talented! I want to see you in the top 3.

3. Hollie -- I think it was a smart choice of song on a night where people were singing well-known-to-them songs. People know that song and vote for song as much as singer. You also stood out in your trio vs. Jessica and Skylar.

4. P2 -- your enjoyment of singing is infectious and a huge part of your appeal

5. Jessica -- I know she is good but seems sorta robotic to me

6. Skylar -- someone seems to have dimmed her light a bit

7. Colton -- your version on you tube was much better. Good voter appeal to the Christian lite rock vote.

Tied for 8th

8. Deandre -- a little falsetto goes a long way for me and an entire song all falsetto seemed to go on for a long time.

9. Heyjun -- the best I have heard you sing but you are not the talent that the many others in the competition are. Time to go.

Don't forget the trios!

ranking:

Elise/P2/Colton -- the best by far; Elise really shone.

Hollie/Jessica/Skylar --Hollie outshone the other 2 girls; Skylar looked like "why do I have to sing Madonna? Why do I have to wear this outfit and hat?"

Joshua/Heyjun/Deandre -- Joshua looked unhapppy at having to sing with Heyjun and Deandre.

I've been doing a thread every week but nobody ever puts there rankings on it so I didn't this week.

1. Elise-great song, her best performance and one of the best of the season (not saying a lot there though )

2. P2-I like him he's the winnern no doubt at all

3. Heejun-boo boring Heejun is back...but his best performance except for last week and we got some bad dancing in trio

4. Deandre-Falshitto extravaganza!!

5. Joshua-not good but better than rest

6. Skylar-yawn and what are they dressing her in?

7. Jessica-she is so boring I can't make it through 3 seconds of song w/o ff

8. Hollie-awful song choice and she hit some bad notes

9. Colton -Gokey 2.0 nuf said

Should be b3 Colton Hollie Jessica

Should go Colton

Will be B3 Joshua Heejun Deandre

Will go DeAndre

LAST EDITED ON 03-29-12 AT 04:30 PM (EST)

#1 - Phillip, Colton and Elise - All 3 were great

#2 - Phillip - Excellent!

#3 - Colton - Maybe his best performance - Final 2 Colton and Phillip still looks very possible.

#4 - Elise - She is getting better, just needs to work on the attitude a little

#5 - Hollie - A better version of Jessica

#6 - Skylar - She doesn't seem to be improving, maybe she hit her peak already.

#7 - Joshua - Not great

#8 - Jessica - She doesn't do it for me

#9 - Jessica, Hollie and Skylar - Meh

#10 - Heejun - Still not good at all

#11 - Heejun, Deandre and Joshua - Horrible!

#12 - Deandre - My ears are still bleeding

Overall - The top 3 for me are clearly Phillip, Colton and Elise
I think we could be do for one of those so called shocking result shows with maybe the save being used tonight. If so it would be Jessica or Joshua.

Should go

Deandre - Gone
Heejun - We have to suffer one more week
Jessica - Bored with her

Will go

Deandre - My ears are saved
Heejun - suffering one more week
Skylar - Safe for now

This is a tough week to predict, they pimped Deandre and Heejun up when everyone knows they are by far the worst left. I think they may want a surprise tonight.

1. Elise

2. Phillip

3. Jessica

4-7 in no particular order: Skylar, Joshua, Hollie, Colton

8-9 in no particular order: DeAndre, Heejun

I can see Hollie being the shocking boot, but I'm thinking that the judges won't save her.