URL: http://community.realitytvworld.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/rtvw2/community/dcboard.cgi
Forum: DCForumID44
Thread Number: 3211
[ Go back to previous page ]

Original Message
"AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by emydi on 03-06-12 at 12:22 PM

PTTE means Picks to the END.
In this game, you want a low score.
Make two lists a WILL GO LIST of how you think the Top 13 will finish.
You can change this list throughout the season but it will cost you +4 points each time you change your list (only one +4 penalty per week)
The 2nd list is my favorite...it's the SHOULD GO list of how YOU would have them finish if you were sole judge. This list YOU CANNOT change ever!!
You get points for how far from accurate your list is..so if think Deandre Vanilli will win this thing and he leaves 13th, you would get 12 points.
Here are your TOP 13 Contestants
Deandre Brackensick
Colton Dixon
Heejun Han
Jermaine Jones
Joshua Ledet
Phillip Phillips
Jeremy Rosado
Hollie Cavanagh
Skylar Laine
Shannon Magrane
Jessica Sanchez
Elise Testone
Erika Van Pelt

Get your lists in by Weds, March 7, 2012 8:00 EST.
BEFORE THE SHOW STARTS!
Don't edit your post after this time or I cannot count it. Any questions, just ask
I'll take your lists from Estee's post.

thanks zazzy!

Table of contents

RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,emydi, 12:25 PM, 03-06-12
RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,emydi, 12:34 PM, 03-06-12
- RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,emydi, 11:11 AM, 03-12-12
RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Snidget, 01:29 PM, 03-06-12
RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,zazzy, 07:59 PM, 03-07-12
- RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,zazzy, 08:59 PM, 03-07-12
  - RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,emydi, 11:54 AM, 03-08-12
Top 13 Week 1 Results,emydi, 11:50 AM, 03-09-12
RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Bob Loblaw, 02:42 AM, 03-11-12
- RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Bob Loblaw, 03:06 AM, 03-11-12
  - RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,csnumber23, 01:35 PM, 03-11-12
    - RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Bob Loblaw, 11:51 PM, 03-11-12
      - RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,emydi, 10:57 AM, 03-12-12
      - RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,csnumber23, 01:41 PM, 03-12-12
        
        RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Bob Loblaw, 11:27 PM, 03-12-12
mrc's picks,mrc, 11:23 AM, 03-12-12
ReDo,Snidget, 08:31 PM, 03-12-12
RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,emydi, 10:00 AM, 03-14-12
- RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,emydi, 10:49 AM, 03-16-12
  - RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,csnumber23, 08:27 PM, 03-16-12
Third time's a charm,emydi, 10:56 AM, 03-16-12
3X,mrc, 11:22 AM, 03-16-12
- RE: 3X,TWoman, 11:34 AM, 03-16-12
  - RE: 3X,emydi, 12:30 PM, 03-16-12
    - RE: 3X,TWoman, 02:57 PM, 03-16-12
  - RE: 3X,agman, 08:20 PM, 03-17-12
Week 1? results,emydi, 11:11 AM, 03-23-12
- Week 2 results,emydi, 10:50 AM, 03-30-12
  - RE: Week 2 results,zazzy, 07:31 PM, 04-04-12
    - RE: Week 2 results,emydi, 11:16 AM, 04-05-12
  - RE: Week 2 results,emydi, 11:21 AM, 04-10-12
    - Week 4 results,emydi, 10:40 AM, 04-20-12
      - Week 5 results,emydi, 10:58 AM, 04-27-12
        
        Week 6 results,emydi, 11:25 AM, 05-04-12
        
        RE: Week 6 results,zazzy, 04:36 PM, 05-04-12
        
        RE: Week 6 results,TWoman, 05:51 PM, 05-04-12
        
        Great picks!,emydi, 10:21 AM, 05-07-12
        
        RE: Week 6 results,emydi, 10:28 AM, 05-11-12
        
        Week 8 results,emydi, 10:08 AM, 05-18-12
        
        Finally Results,emydi, 10:53 AM, 05-24-12
- RE: Week 1? results,Bob Loblaw, 11:14 PM, 04-26-12
  - RE: Week 1? results,emydi, 10:43 AM, 04-27-12
A little something for our winners!E: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,emydi, 02:32 PM, 05-30-12
- RE: A little something for our winners!E: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,TWoman, 08:44 PM, 05-31-12

Messages in this discussion

"RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by emydi on 03-06-12 at 12:25 PM

this is what we have over in Estee's thread
csnumber23
Should Go
13 - Heejun Han (Don't know how he is even here still)
12 - Deandre Brackensick ( I knew they would save him)
11 - Jeremy Rosado
10 - Jessica Sanchez (way over rated to me)
9 - Shannon Magrane
8 - Erika Van Pelt ( I like her but she will never get this far)
7 - Hollie Cavanaugh
6 - Joshua Ledet
5 - Jermaine Jones (glad he is back in)
4 - Elise Testone
3 - Skylar Laine (dark horse)
2 - Colton Dixon (runner-up)
1 - Phil Phillips(winner)
Will Go
13 - Erika Van Pelt(we all know a girl has to go first)
12 - Jeremy Rosado (Jennifer will want to save but not unanimous)
11 - Heejun Han
10 - Shannon Magrane ( Here's hoping 5 girls make the tour)
9 - Hollie Cavanaugh ( a tough one to predict were she will go out)
8 - Deandre Brackensick ( this years Stefano, saved, makes my ears bleed more and lasts way too long.)
7 - Elise Testone (this is one that could actually be gone first)
6 - Joshua Ledet
5 - Jessica Sanchez
4 - Jermaine Jones
3 - Skylar Laine (possible finalist and only other potential winner)
2 - Colton Dixon (runner-up)
1 - Phil Phillips (winner)
Both lists it's a toss up for me between Phil Phillips and Colton Dixon as to who should and who will win. I think it could go either way. If a girl is going to win, i know the show wants Jessica Sanchez but I think the last girl standing and only one that could win is Skylar Laine. Joshua Ledet is my prediction for the early save this year. I think it's him or Jessica Sanchez.

mrc
Should go:
13. DeAndre Brackensick: Waste of time.
12. Jermaine Jones: Like his personality, but he's no match for this competition.
11. Hollie Cavanagh: Not that great.
10. Heejun Han: See #12. I like how he gives the finger to the AI establishment, but he won't (and shouldn't) last long.
9. Jessica Sanchez: I didn't think she was that great.
8. Shannon Magrane: See #11. Middle-of-the-road talent.
7. Jeremy Rosado: Good kid, not top-tier.
6. Skylar Laine: Too yelly for my taste. Like Reba on crack.
5. Erika Van Pelt: A better talent than Skylar.
4. Colton Dixon: Probably a talented guy, but I haven't seen anything "wow" from him.
3. Joshua Ledet: A legit Af Am male contender.
2. Phillip Phillips: WGWG, but I like him.
1. Elise Testone: Easily the best singer left.
Will go:
13. Hollie Cavanagh: Wallflower will get lost in the shuffle.
12. Jermaine Jones: Will likely collapse from the pressure.
11. Jessica Sanchez: Will probably be saved.
10. DeAndre Brackensick: Should be first out, but will make it to tour. If Jessica is saved, DeAndre will be the one out next, followed by Jessica.
9. Jeremy Rosado: Not enough personality to make an impression.
8. Heejun Han: Fun ride comes to an end.
7. Shannon Magrane: Won't stand out enough to survive longer.
6. Joshua Ledet: Will share the fate of other Af Am males, such as . . . um, yeah.
5. Erika Van Pelt: Unfortunately, will be cut to help along the guys.
4. Elise Testone: Travesty.
3. Colton Dixon: Pimping gets him this far.
2. Phillip Phillips: WGWG has to make F2. It's in AI's contract.
1. Skylar Laine: The female Scotty. "But a female finally won!" Blech.
Belle Book
Should go:
13. DeAndre Brackensick
12. Heejun Han
11. Jeremy Rosado
10. Skylar Laine (I think she's the weakest vocally amongst the girls)
9. Colton Dixon
8. Phillip Phillips
7. Erika Van Pelt
6. Shannon Magrane
5. Jermaine Jones
4. Joshua Ledet
3. Elise Testone
2. Hollie Cavanagh
1. Jessica Sanchez
Will go:
13. DeAndre -- wildcard, widely viewed as weakest singer, will be mediocre.
12. Jermaine -- will be competing for votes with Joshua.
11. Erika -- wildcard & will be competing for votes with Elise.
10. Shannon -- too bland.
9. Heejun -- I love him but he's not good enough.
8. Jeremy -- at least he won't finish last.
7. Colton -- Phillip is a little better than Colton and Heejun fans will have switched to Phillip.
6. Joshua -- not memorable enough.
5. Elise -- older people don't vote en masse (usually).
4. Hollie -- will be competing for votes with Jessica.
3. Skylar -- the country vote won't be enough this time.
2. Phillip -- the wgwg trend will end at last.
1. Jessica -- my favorite will finally win American Idol!

VFTW
Will go:
13) Erika
12) DeAndre
11) Jermaine
10) Hollie
9) Heejun
8) Jeremy
7) Jessica
6) Joshua
5) Skylar
4) Elise
3) Colton
2) Phillip
1) Shannon

"RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by emydi on 03-06-12 at 12:34 PM

LAST EDITED ON 03-07-12 AT 01:51 PM (EST)
Should go
13 Deandre Brackensick
12 Jeremy Rosado
11 Erika Van Pelt (that's some wcs for ya, judges!)
10 Colton Dixon
9 Jessica Sanchez
8 Shannon Magrane
7 Jermaine Jones
6 Elise Testone
5 Hollie Cavanagh
4 Skylar Laine
3 Joshua Ledet
2 Phillip Phillips
1 Heejun Han BFFs forever!

Will go
13 Erika Van Pelt
12 Jeremy Rosado
11 Hollie Cavanagh
10 Deandre Brackensick (they want the hair for the tour)
9 Heejun Han
8 Jermaine Jones
7 Elise Testone
6 Shannon Magrane
5 Jessica Sanchez
4 Joshua Ledet
3 Skylar Laine
2 Colton Dixon
1 Phillip Phillips WGWG5! VFTW Victory!

"RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by emydi on 03-12-12 at 11:11 AM

New list!1
Should go
12 Colton Dixon
11 Shannon Magrane
10 Deandre Brackensick
9 Jessica Sanchez
8 Jermaine Jones
7 Erika Van Pelt
6 Joshua Ledet
5 Elise Testone
4 Hollie Cavanagh
3 Skylar Laine
2 Phillip Phillips
1 Heejun Han
Will go
12 Erika Van Pelt
11 Shannon Magrane
10 Jermaine Jones
9 Deandre Brackensick
8 Heejun Han
7 Elise Testone
6 Joshua Ledet
5 Hollie Cavanagh
4 Jessica Sanchez
3 Skylar Laine
2 Colton Dixon
1 Phillip Phillips

"RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Snidget on 03-06-12 at 01:29 PM

Will Go-- Worst Case Scenario
13 Elise Testone
12 Shannon Magrane
11 Erika Van Pelt
10 Jessica Sanchez
9 Hollie Cavanaugh
8 Deandre Brackensick
7 Skylar Lane
6 Jeremy Rosado
5 Heejun Han
4 Joshua Ledet
3 Jermaine Jones
2 Colton Dixon
1 Phillip Phillips
Should Go
13 Colton Dixon--Sure you weren't really there to audition
12 Jeremy Rosado--Just doesn't do it for me.
11 Deandre Brackensick--another retread from a previous season
10 Erika Van Pelt--for the tatoo alone
9 Joshua Ledet--just a bit too much screeching diva
8 Elise Testone--just seems about here for me
7 Hollie Cavanagh--just a bit too much stealth TCO fumes around her for me so I don't want her to near the end
6 Shannon Magrane--just for standing next to Ryan purposes
5 Phillip Phillips--gotta give it to anyone seeing the trend and working the WGWG angle
4 Skylar Laine--At least she tries to entertain, more Tina/Reba fusion performances please
3 Jermaine Jones--more standing next to Ryan joy.
2 Jessica Sanchez--watch the heds explode with this final two
1 Heejun Han-just for the LOL's

"RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by zazzy on 03-07-12 at 07:59 PM

LAST EDITED ON 03-07-12 AT 08:56 PM (EST)

Will go:
1. Hollie --winner
2. Jessica
3. Phillip
4. Joshua
5. Skylar
6. Colton
7. Shannon
8. HeyJun
9. Elise
10.Deandre
11.Jermaine
12.Erica
13.Jeremy --first out

Should go (never going to happen due to airtime and pimpage so far):
1. Hollie -- winner
2. Phil
3. Joshua
4. Jessica
5. Elise
6. Skylar
7. Shannon
8. Erica
9. Colton
10. Deandre
11. Hey Jun
12. Jermaine
13. Jeremy - first boot

"RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by zazzy on 03-07-12 at 08:59 PM

I don't know why the edited post says 8:56p-- it is only 7:59 right now! On to AI 13!

"RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by emydi on 03-08-12 at 11:54 AM

np all good

"Top 13 Week 1 Results"
Posted by emydi on 03-09-12 at 11:50 AM

LAST EDITED ON 03-12-12 AT 10:59 AM (EST)
I'm just putting the results all in this thread. Put any changes to WILL GO Lists here also
Should go
zazzy 0 way to go z!
Smidge 1
emy 1
Belle 2
csno 2
mrc 6
Will go
zazzy 0 way to go z!
csno 1
emy 1
mrc 4
Belle 5
VFTW 5
Smidge 7

I'm wiping the slate clean guys...You can edit your WG/SG lists by Weds. show 3/14/12 8pm EDT!

"RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Bob Loblaw on 03-11-12 at 02:42 AM

As per his usual custom, Mr. Bob Loblaw prefers to wait until after week 1 performances to call his shot, taking the 4 point hit right off the bat. Therefore.....
Should go:
13. Jeremy
12. DeAndre
11. Elise
10. Skylar
9. Jermaine
8. Skylar
7. Holly
6. Joshua
5. Colton
4. Erika
3. Jessica
2. HeeJun
1. Phil Phillips
Will go:
13. Jeremy
12. Elise
11. DeAndre
10. Jermaine
9. Shannon
8. Holly
7. Joshua
6. Skylar
5. Colton
4. HeeJun
3. Erika
2. Jessica
1. Phillip Phillips - WInner!

"RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Bob Loblaw on 03-11-12 at 03:06 AM

oops! Should go typo!
10 skylar
should read
10 shannon
thanks!

"RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by csnumber23 on 03-11-12 at 01:35 PM

You have to turn it in before week 1 to count. Just a bit easier after seeing who was in the bottom 3 of each and then bottom 2 in week 1. LOL

"RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Bob Loblaw on 03-11-12 at 11:51 PM

Since when do we just make up new rules that crowd people out of the contest? I've been doing this for like eight years, and I probably only got my list in before week 1 maybe twice in that time.
What's the difference between submitting any old list week 1 and then immediately changing it for a 4-pt penalty, vs. submitting nothing week 1 and taking a 4 pt penalty for starting late? I've said for years that we should start the lists after week 1, because of the ridiculously unequal coverage of the different contestants throughout auditions and Hollywood weeks.
It's not a very friendly move to proclaim yourself the rulemaker and start squeezing out people who've been playing this for years. My take was that this was supposed to be something done for fun, among long-time fans of the show.
What say we lighten up a bit, here?

"RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by emydi on 03-12-12 at 10:57 AM

You know what? Bob is probably right about week 1....let's wipe the slate clean and anyone can put new/revised WG/SG lists in this week before the Weds. show starts!!
Yay!

"RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by csnumber23 on 03-12-12 at 01:41 PM

WOW, couldn't you tell I was joking? I typed a big LOL, sorry it was meant to be a joke. I certainly don't care when people turn them in. It isn't even my contest it's Emyd's.

"RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Bob Loblaw on 03-12-12 at 11:27 PM

Sorry, CS--I overreacted. In my defense, I thought you were going to take away my PTTE this year! "Nobody puts Bobby in a corner...."
Great idea, Emydi....just for that, you can call me Mr. Blah Blah.... I'll tell EnglProf to get her picks in soon.

"mrc's picks"
Posted by mrc on 03-12-12 at 11:23 AM

Should go:
12. DeAndre Brackensick: Waste of time.
11. Jermaine Jones: Like his personality, but he's no match for this competition.
10. Hollie Cavanagh: Not that great.
9. Heejun Han: See #12. I like how he gives the finger to the AI establishment, but he won't (and shouldn't) last long.
8. Jessica Sanchez: I didn't think she was that great.
7. Shannon Magrane: See #11. Middle-of-the-road talent.
6. Skylar Laine: Too yelly for my taste. Like Reba on crack.
5. Erika Van Pelt: A better talent than Skylar.
4. Colton Dixon: Probably a talented guy, but I haven't seen anything "wow" from him.
3. Joshua Ledet: A legit Af Am male contender.
2. Phillip Phillips: WGWG, but I like him.
1. Elise Testone: Easily the best singer left.
Will go:
12. Jermaine Jones
11. Shannon Magrane
10. Elise Testone
9. Hollie Cavanagh
8. Jessica Sanchez
7. DeAndre Brackensick
6. Heejun Han
5. Joshua Ledet
4. Erika Van Pelt
3. Colton Dixon
2. Phillip Phillips
1. Skylar Laine
A Slice of Manga

"ReDo"
Posted by Snidget on 03-12-12 at 08:31 PM

Will Go
12 Shannon Magrane  
11 Elise Testone
10 Heejun Han
9 Erika Van Pelt  
8 Jessica Sanchez  
7 Jermaine Jones  
6 Hollie Cavanaugh
 5 Joshua Ledet
4 Deandre Brackensick
 3 Skylar Lane
 2 Colton Dixon
 1 Phillip Phillips

Should Go
12 Colton Dixon--Sure you weren't really there to audition 
11 Deandre Brackensick--another retread from a previous season 
10 Erika Van Pelt--for the tatoo alone 
9 Joshua Ledet--just a bit too much screeching diva
 8 Elise Testone--just seems about here for me 
7 Hollie Cavanagh--just a bit too much stealth TCO fumes around her for me so I don't want her to near the end
 6 Shannon Magrane--just for standing next to Ryan purposes 
5 Phillip Phillips--gotta give it to anyone seeing the trend and working the WGWG angle 
4 Skylar Laine--At least she tries to entertain, more Tina/Reba fusion performances please 
3 Jermaine Jones--more standing next to Ryan joy.
 2 Jessica Sanchez--watch the heads explode with this final two
 1 Heejun Han-just for the LOL's

"RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by emydi on 03-14-12 at 10:00 AM

LAST EDITED ON 03-14-12 AT 02:24 PM (EST)
The deadline for new lists is next week go to VFTW for details
New players are encouraged to enter!!!
........is anybody out there......

"RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by emydi on 03-16-12 at 10:49 AM

We'll start at the TOP 10 TOUR!!!!
Put in your new lists by Wed. March 21, 2012 8 p.m. EDT

"RE: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by csnumber23 on 03-16-12 at 08:27 PM

Should Go
10 - Heejun Han (Don't know how he is even here still)
9 - Deandre Brackensick (Almost as bad as Heejun)
8 - Erika Van Pelt
7 - Jessica Sanchez
6 - Elise Testone
5 - Joshua Ledet
4 - Hollie Cavanaugh
3 - Skylar Laine (dark horse)
2 - Colton Dixon (runner-up)
1 - Phil Phillips(winner)
Will Go
10 - Erika Van Pelt(we all know a girl has to go first)
9 - Heejun Han (Horrible and never should have made the tour)
8 - Elise Testone ( Glad she made the tour)
7 - Deandre Brackensick ( this years Stefano, saved, makes my ears bleed more and lasts way too long.)
6 - Jessica Sanchez
5 - Joshua Ledet
4 - Hollie Cavanaugh
3 - Skylar Laine (possible finalist and only other potential winner besides top 2)
2 - Colton Dixon (runner-up)
1 - Phil Phillips (winner)
Both lists it's a toss up for me between Phil Phillips and Colton Dixon as to who should and who will win. I think it could go either way.I am sticking with my original pick of Phillip but I now think it might be Colton. If a girl is going to win, i know the show wants Jessica Sanchez but I think the last girl standing and only one that could win is Skylar Laine. Joshua Ledet is my prediction for the early save this year. I think it's him or Jessica Sanchez.

"Third time's a charm"
Posted by emydi on 03-16-12 at 10:56 AM

Should go
10 Colton Dixon
9 Jessica Sanchez
8 Deandre Brackensik
7 Heejun Han
6 Erika Van Pelt
5 Skylar Laine
4 Hollie Cavanagh
3 Elise Testone
2 Phillip Phillips
1 Joshua Ledet
Will go
10 Erika Van Pelt
9 Elise Testone
8 Heejun Han
7 Deandre Brackensick
6 Jessica Sanchez
5 Hollie Cavanagh
4 Skylar Laine
3 Joshua Ledet
2 Colton Dixon
1 Phillip Phillips

"3X"
Posted by mrc on 03-16-12 at 11:22 AM

Should go:
10. DeAndre Brackensick: Waste of time.
9. Heejun Han: I like how he gives the finger to the AI establishment, but he won't (and shouldn't) last long.
8. Jessica Sanchez: I didn't think she was that great.
7. Skylar Laine: Too yelly for my taste. Like Reba on crack.
6. Erika Van Pelt: A better talent than Skylar.
5. Colton Dixon: Probably a talented guy, but I haven't seen anything "wow" from him.
4. 10. Hollie Cavanagh: I've changed my mind about her. She could be a dark horse for F3.
3. Joshua Ledet: A legit Af Am male contender.
2. Phillip Phillips: WGWG, but I like him.
1. Elise Testone: Easily the best singer left.
Will go:
10. Elise Testone: If she doesn't suck up and play the game, America is sending her home next. Plus, see #8.
9. Heejun Han: The AI Establishment want him out sooner rather than later.
8. Erika Van Pelt: Not pencil-thin? Outta here. America hates singers who look normal. (Adele Fever is her only hope.)
7. DeAndre Brackensick: Would have gone home sooner w/o the hair.
6. Jessica Sanchez: The most shocking.elimination.ever. She'll be saved, and DeAndre will go home first.
5. Skylar Laine: America's going to get tired of her yelling and stomping.
4. Joshua Ledet: Too black for primetime TV.
3. Hollie Cavanagh: I can see she and Josh flipping places, but AI wants to at least act like a female can win.
2. Phillip Phillips: Could be 1st, but I think Colton's hair wins the competition.
1. Colton Dixon: The AI pimp machine will seal the deal by requiring him to play a guitar every week.
A Slice of Manga

"RE: 3X"
Posted by TWoman on 03-16-12 at 11:34 AM

Should Go
10. Deandre, Deandre, Deandre (his hair can stay)
9. Heejun
8. Erika
7. Skylar
6. Colton
5. Elise
4. Jessica
3. Hollie
2. Phil
1. Joshua
Will go
10. Erika
9. Heejun
8. Elise
7. Deandre
6. Skylar
5. Colton
4. Hollie
3. Joshua
2. Jessica
1. Phil

"RE: 3X"
Posted by emydi on 03-16-12 at 12:30 PM

Yay! a new contestant! Come on down!

"RE: 3X"
Posted by TWoman on 03-16-12 at 02:57 PM

Thanks!

"RE: 3X"
Posted by agman on 03-17-12 at 08:20 PM

Welcome to the boards!

"Week 1? results"
Posted by emydi on 03-23-12 at 11:11 AM

Ok really this time it counts
Should go
TWoman 2
csno 2
Smidge 2
zazzy 3
emy 4
mrc 4
Belle 5
Bob 6
Way to go TW cs and Smidge!
Will go
zazzy 0
TWoman 0
csno 0
emy 0
Belle 1
mrc 2
Smidge 2
Bob 7
Way to go z TW cs and me
Any changes due Wed 3/28/12 8 pm edt

"Week 2 results"
Posted by emydi on 03-30-12 at 10:50 AM

Weekly
Should go
Belle 0
TWoman 0
mrc 0
csno 1
zazzy 1
emy 2
Bob 7
Smidge 8
Way to go Belle TW and mrc!
Overall
Should go
TWoman 2
cs 3
mrc 4
zazzy 4
Belle 5
emy 6
Smidge 10
Bob 13
Way to go TWoman!
Weekly
Will go
csno 0
mrc 0
Smidge 0
TWoman 0
Belle 1
emy 1
zazzy 2
Bob 5
Way to go cs mrc Smidge and TW!
Overall
Will go
csno 0
TWoman 0
emy 1
Belle 2
mrc 2
Smidge 2
zazzy 2
Bob 12
Way to go cs and TW!
Any changes due Wed 4/4/12 8 pm edt

"RE: Week 2 results"
Posted by zazzy on 04-04-12 at 07:31 PM

Hi Em, I had Heyjun going at 8th...do you have the right list for me? I have not changed mine yet...

"RE: Week 2 results"
Posted by emydi on 04-05-12 at 11:16 AM

I took out the earlier boots bc they didn't count (Shannon) and that moved Heejun to 7 for you

"RE: Week 2 results"
Posted by emydi on 04-10-12 at 11:21 AM

LAST EDITED ON 04-10-12 AT 11:21 AM (EST)
Whoops! This is Week 3 results!
Weekly
Should go
emy 0
Smidge 1
zazzy 1
csno 1
Belle 2
TWoman 2
mrc 2
Bob 2
Way to go me!
Overall
Should go
TWoman 4
csno 4
zazzy 5
mrc 6
emy 6
Belle 7
Smidge 11
Bob 15
Way to go TWoman and cs!
Weekly
Will go
csno 1
mrc 1
Bob 1
TWoman 1
zazzy 1
emy 1
Belle 2
Smidge 4
Way to go cs mrc Bob TW zazzy and me!
Overall
Will go
csno 1
TWoman 1
emy 2
zazzy 3
mrc 3
Belle 4
Smidge 6
Bob 13
Way to go cs and TW!

Any changes due Wed 4/11/12 8 pm edt

"Week 4 results"
Posted by emydi on 04-20-12 at 10:40 AM

SHOULD GO
Weekly
Belle 0
TWoman 1
zazzy 1
mrc 2
Bob 2
Smidge 3
emy 3
csno 5
Way to go Belle!
Overall
TWoman 5
zazzy 6
Belle 7
mrc 8
csno 9
emy 9
Smidge 14
Bob 17
Way to go TWoman!
WILL GO
Weekly
Belle 0
zazzy 1
Bob 2
TWoman 2
csno 5
Smidge 5
emy 5
mrc 6
Way to go Belle Nice week!
Overall
TWoman 3
Belle 4
zazzy 4
csno 6
emy 7
mrc 9
Smidge 11
Bob 15
Way to go TW! Leader in both lists!

Any changes due Wed 4/25/12 8 pm edt

"Week 5 results"
Posted by emydi on 04-27-12 at 10:58 AM

SHOULD GO
Weekly
csno23 0
Smidge 0
TWoman 1
zazzy 1
Belle 3
Bob 3
emy 3
mrc 5
Way to go cs and Smidge!
Overall
TWoman 6
zazzy 7
csno23 9
Belle 10
emy 12
mrc 13
Smidge 14
Bob 20
Way to go TWoman!
WILL GO
Weekly
Belle 1
zazzy 2
TWoman 2
csno23 2
emy 3
Bob 4
Smidge 4
mrc 4
Way to go Belle!
Overall
Belle 5
TWoman 5
zazzy 6
csno23 8
emy 10
mrc 13
Smidge 15
Bob 19
Way to go Belle and TW!

Any changes due Wed 5/2/12 8 pm edt

"Week 6 results"
Posted by emydi on 05-04-12 at 11:25 AM

SHOULD GO
Weekly
emy 0
zazzy 1
mrc 2
csno23 2
Smidge 2
TWoman 2
Belle 3
Bob 3
Way to go me!

Overall
TWoman 8
zazzy 8
csno23 11
emy 12
Belle 13
mrc 15
Smidge 16
Bob 23
Way to go TWoman and z!
WILL GO (not P2 vftw victory)
Weekly
mrc 0
zazzy 0
Bob 1
TWoman 1
emy 1
Smidge 2
Belle 2
csno23 2
Way to go mrc and z!
Overall
zazzy 6
TWoman 6
Belle 7
csno23 10
emy 11
mrc 13
Smidge 17
Bob 20
Way to go z and TW!
Any changes due Wed 5/9/12 8 pm edt

"RE: Week 6 results"
Posted by zazzy on 05-04-12 at 04:36 PM

Em, thanks for running the game!
I am happy I was able to pick the top 4 and not change my list from the beginning. ....and then I saw that Twoman has the same top 4 (way to go!) and they are in a more-likely-to-go order than mine, so this is the week I enjoy being at the top of the heap ... before the rug gets pulled from underneath Hollie.
But, if you go back to the top 13 performances, and look at the judges' comments to Hollie, Jlo winks at Steve as she predicts a girl vs girl top 2, so it could still happen!
Jessica has not yet had the pimp spot so that's an indicator of her popularity despite needing the save from the judges. We saw Phil's fan base come through after a weak night for him. Joshua may have been propped up by a pimp spot, although I think he has what it takes to win, and that can happen if he continues to outshine the other 3. That leaves Hollie and the Holliepops as the fodder at F4...but the show has had her be the one to stand next to the bootee each week for awhile. Jess is probably primed for the pimp spot this week.
Hollie already went first this week.
Next show will be interesting!
So thanks again, Em, and congrats to Twoman!

"RE: Week 6 results"
Posted by TWoman on 05-04-12 at 05:51 PM

Thanks Zazzy! I'm as shocked as anyone that I haven't had to change my picks and that the last 4 standing were my top 4 from the start. I think these 4 could go in just about any order so it's still a horse race.
thanks for hosting Em!

"Great picks!"
Posted by emydi on 05-07-12 at 10:21 AM

You both have the top 4 still left in both lists (albeit in different orders!)
Good Luck!

"RE: Week 6 results"
Posted by emydi on 05-11-12 at 10:28 AM

LAST EDITED ON 05-11-12 AT 10:29 AM (EST)
crap..i forgot to change title it's week 7 results!
SHOULD GO
Weekly
csno23 0
mrc 0
emy 0
Smidge 1
TWoman 1
Belle 2
Bob 3
zazzy 3
Way to go cs mrc and me!

Overall
TWoman 9
csno23 11
zazzy 11
emy 12
Belle 15
mrc 15
Smidge 17
Bob 26
Way to go TWoman!

WILL GO
Weekly
Belle 0
csno23 0
TWoman 0
mrc 1
emy 1
Smidge 2
zazzy 3
Bob 4
Way to go Belle and cs--nice cs a 0 score for the week!

Overall
TWoman 6
Belle 7
zazzy 9
csno23 10
emy 12
mrc 14
Smidge 19
Bob 24

Way to go TW!

Any changes due Wed 5/16/12 8 pm edt

"Week 8 results"
Posted by emydi on 05-18-12 at 10:08 AM

SHOULD GO
Weekly
zazzy 0
mrc 0
Belle 1
TWoman 2
csno23 2
emy 2
Bob 3
Smidge 4
Way to go zazzy and mrc!

Overall
zazzy 11
TWoman 11
csno23 13
emy 14
mrc 15
Belle 16
Smidge 21
Bob 29
Way to go zazzy and TWoman!
WILL GO
Weekly
TWoman 0
emy 0
mrc 1
zazzy 1
csno23 2
Smidge 2
Belle 3
Bob 4
Way to go TWoman and me!

Overall
TWoman 6
Belle 10
zazzy 10
csno23 12
emy 12
mrc 15
Smidge 21
Bob 28

Way to go TW!

Any changes due Tues 5/22/12 8pm edt

"Finally Results"
Posted by emydi on 05-24-12 at 10:53 AM

SHOULD GO
Weekly
Bob 1 (PP correct)
Smidge 3 (JS correct wha?)
zazzy 3
TWoman 3
csno23 5 (PP correct)
Belle 6
mrc 7
emy 8
Overall
zazzy 14
TWoman 14
csno23 18
Belle 22
mrc 22
emy 22
Smidge 24
Bob 30
Way to go zazzy and TWoman!

WILL GO
Weekly
TWoman 0 (both correct, actually Final 4 correct)
Bob 0 (both correct)
Belle 2
zazzy 2 (JS correct)
csno23 4 (PP correct)
emy 4 (PP correct)
mrc 5
Smidge 5 (PP correct)
Overall
TWoman 6 (amazing score!)
Belle 12
zazzy 12
csno23 16
emy 16
mrc 20
Smidge 26
Bob 28
Way to go TW!!
Not sure if I'll be back next year....they may mess around with voting and give the yahoos at the judge's table more say...I couldn't stomach that...but how much power do the frauen have to crown WGWG#6? Like Estee said they may just bar WGWGs from the pool

"RE: Week 1? results"
Posted by Bob Loblaw on 04-26-12 at 11:14 PM

hey emydi--
Why did I get 6 points this week? I had shannon going at 9, and she "went" at 11 the first week it counted...
Should I have 2 for this week 1?

"RE: Week 1? results"
Posted by emydi on 04-27-12 at 10:43 AM

the first week it counted was at top 10 bc I was not sure is there would be an elimination when Jermaine left
the first week was Erika at 10 and you had her at 4

"A little something for our winners!E: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by emydi on 05-30-12 at 02:32 PM

LAST EDITED ON 05-30-12 AT 02:37 PM (EST)

Please thank agman!!

"RE: A little something for our winners!E: AI11 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by TWoman on 05-31-12 at 08:44 PM

Love it! Thanks for hosting!