Top 10 Rankings, for the most part I was not crazy about the performances in my favorite theme week. (Rock)

#1 - Josh - By far, nobody even close in my opinion

#2 - Melanie - Good performance but would have liked more upbeat for rock week.

#3 - Rachel - At least she changed it up

#4 - Leroy - Not his best but I still liked it

#5 - Lakoda Rain - I liked everything but the dancers up there to Fleetwood Mac

#6 - Marcus - Not great vocals but he performed and at least tried to rock

#7 - Drew - I love U2 and her slowed down version she always does didn't cut it for me.

#8 - Astro - LA criticizes others for doing the same but this kid just rapped in rock week. He can rap for sure but nothing else added to it.

#9 - Chris - Bob Marley?? Bob Marley?? I don't need to say more when it's rock week. Plus he really can't sing

#10 - Stacy - Horrible and she needs to go

Overall - To me Josh is by far the most talented but I still don't think he'll win. I think it's between the 3 girls but now I think Malanie and Rachel are both ahead of Drew

Should go

Stacy - gone
Chris - saved

Will go

Stacy - gone
Marcus - saved

It easily could be the last group in the bottom again but I think it's between Marcus and Leroy to join Stacy.

• RE: Top 10 Rankings,Estee, 11:13 AM, 11-17-11
• RE: Top 10 Rankings,emydi, 01:00 PM, 11-17-11
• RE: Top 10 Rankings,tomola, 01:08 PM, 11-17-11

LAST EDITED ON 11-17-11 AT 11:16 AM (EST)

1. Josh
2. Rachel
3. Leroy
4. Melanie

Here go hell come.

5. Lakoda Rayne
6. Chris
7. Astro
8. Drew
9. Marcus
10. Stacey

Should:

Stacy (merit)
Marcus: out (wrong genre and misplaced backlash against the stage show)

Will:

Drew (shocker!)
Lakoda Rayne: out (Paula has her anti-perfect game.)

1. Josh-only one to really rock

2. Astro-everyone else didn't rock and he's was the best at "not rocking" and he writes his own stuff every week

3. Leroy-I love his voice, love it. I wish he would have sung "Turn the Page" instead (he could have done it Metallica style and really rocked )

4. Melanie-I hate that song hate it. (But I love REM) Her voice is really nice though

5. Chris-I like this kid, he's found his niche I think.

6. Marcus-meh but he did try to rock like cs said

7. Rachel-I did not like this at all. I thought it was an awful choice of song for her

8. Drew-oooooooooooooommmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh can she sing any slower and whinier?

9. Lakoda Rayne-awful imho

10. Fakethis-if looks could kill, geez

B2

Should be LR and Fake
Will be LR and Marcus

Go

Should Fake
Will LR

LAST EDITED ON 11-17-11 AT 01:09 PM (EST)

Most of all i like Rachel. For my she is favorite.