OMG i am sick of this there is a message in the name of the show its IDOL. Pia although a good singer wasnt an idol she wasnt likable. I have never thought she couldnt sing i felt that she was walled in it was as if she was too good for the competition and it dont matter how good a singer you are if people dont or cant relate to you you will never be an IDOL

• RE: Pia,csnumber23, 11:51 PM, 04-10-11
  • RE: Pia,anlin, 00:47 AM, 04-11-11
• RE: Pia,geekboy, 08:24 AM, 04-11-11
  • RE: Pia,csnumber23, 06:07 PM, 04-13-11
• And...........,agman, 10:14 AM, 04-15-11
  • RE: And...........,JessicaRN, 02:47 PM, 04-15-11
• RE: Pia,TARFAN76, 11:59 PM, 04-19-11
• RE: Pia,TARFAN76, 11:59 PM, 04-19-11

She was completely over rated in my opinion. Gorgeous to look at and a good voice but no performing skills at all. No versatility at all. While I don't think she should have gone before Stefano or Paul, I didn't mind her elimination.

I understand what you are saying however they have tried other thigs for weeks she did ballad after ballad they kept asking her for somthing differnt but to no availe. Well maybe she will have had it all recorded so she can look back on it and realise that the people are right and shes not an "Idol" you have to be likeable

Maybe I missed the memo, but I still thought this was a show where the viewing public voted...and the person with the least votes was voted off....If that is still the case, why is Pia getting so much attention? Just because JLo loved her and wanted her in the finals? So sorry, JLo. Will we be making this much fuss every damn week now when *SHOCKER* someone gets voted off?

Also, i thought the judges comments were insulting to Stefano.

Geekboy

"I think what Randy Travis was trying to say was 'What the hell was that?!'" - S. Cowell

LAST EDITED ON 04-13-11 AT 06:08 PM (EST)

I agree completely Geekboy, they were insulting to all the contestants and specifically Stefano.

The judges acted like fools and should be ashamed with themselves. For me, there is a lot of talent this year and these judges are ruining the show!

I agree with the post from Anlin as well!

If she's really as good as the judges think she is(cough cough)then she should be able to make it even though she got voted off the show. She has certainly had plenty of exposure and publicity.

Good point, and perhaps one of the judges could bankroll her while her career is getting off of the ground. Of course, she lost on a vote from "America" so maybe she wouldn't sell that many.

I'm smirking about Pia's career ever "getting off the ground.". WTF? Yeah, rush her to the studio while a couple of suckers still agree with her own boring assessment of 5-year-old Pia "I thought I was a superstar.". Well, I never did and I could not have been happier to see her boring diva perfection to get the boot. Good singer? Yeah. Pretty? I guess - as she certainly believed...Personality? Z I P. And didn't she look pleasant in the audience? Not a bit.

LAST EDITED ON 04-20-11 AT 00:01 AM (EST)

I'm smirking about Pia's career ever "getting off the ground.". WTF? Yeah, rush her to the studio while a couple of suckers still agree with her own boring assessment of 5-year-old Pia "I thought I was a superstar.". Well, I never did and I could not have been happier to see her boring diva perfection to get the boot. Good singer? Yeah. Pretty? I guess - as she certainly believed...Personality? Z I P. And didn't she look pleasant in the audience? Not a bit.