URL: http://community.realitytvworld.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/rtvw2/community/dcboard.cgi
Forum: DCForumID44
Thread Number: 3040
[ Go back to previous page ]
Original Message
"AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by emydi on 03-04-11 at 12:22 PM

PTTE means Picks to the END. In this game, you want a low score.

Make two lists a WILL GO LIST of how you think the Top 13 will finish. You can change this list throughout the season but it will cost you +4 points each time you change your list (only one +4 penalty per week)

The 2nd list is my favorite...it's the SHOULD GO list of how YOU would have them finish if you were sole judge. This list YOU CANNOT change ever!!

You get points for how far from accurate your list is..so if think Ashthon will win this thing and she leaves 13th, you would get 12 points.

Here are your TOP 13 Contestants

Ashton Jones
Haley Reinhart
Karen Rodriguez
Lauren Alaina Suddeth
Naima Adedap
Pia Toscano
Thia Megia
Casey Abrams
Jacob Lusk
James Durbin
Paul McDonald
Scotty McCreery
Stefano Langone

Get your lists in by Weds, March 9, 2010 8:00 EST. BEFORE THE SHOW STARTS

Don't edit your post after this time or I cannot count it. Any questions, just ask


Recycling is cool!

Table of contents
  • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,emydi, 12:30 PM, 03-04-11
    • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Tummy, 07:11 PM, 03-04-11
      • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,cahaya, 07:56 PM, 03-04-11
        • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Tummy, 08:05 PM, 03-04-11
          • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,batts, 01:47 AM, 03-06-11
  • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Belle Book, 09:50 PM, 03-05-11
    • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,emydi, 05:52 PM, 03-10-11
  • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,cahaya, 12:33 PM, 03-06-11
  • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,djandy, 00:48 AM, 03-07-11
  • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Tummy, 05:43 PM, 03-07-11
  • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,batts, 05:22 AM, 03-08-11
  • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,csnumber23, 09:22 AM, 03-08-11
    • I can start the funoffice pool, if that is the one you meant,Snidget, 12:19 PM, 03-08-11
      • RE: I can start the funoffice pool, if that is the one you meant,emydi, 02:08 PM, 03-08-11
      • RE: I can start the funoffice pool, if that is the one you meant,csnumber23, 02:15 PM, 03-08-11
      • RE: I can start the funoffice pool, if that is the one you meant,cahaya, 06:38 PM, 03-09-11
  • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Snidget, 12:28 PM, 03-08-11
  • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,mrc, 02:41 PM, 03-08-11
    • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,mrc, 02:42 PM, 03-08-11
      • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,mrc, 12:55 PM, 03-10-11
  • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,zazzy, 06:58 PM, 03-08-11
  • Corvis' Picks,Corvis, 06:27 PM, 03-09-11
  • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,frodis, 06:41 PM, 03-09-11
  • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Bob Loblaw, 01:58 AM, 03-10-11
    • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Corvis, 08:43 PM, 03-10-11
      • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Bob Loblaw, 11:44 PM, 03-10-11
        • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Tummy, 10:36 AM, 03-11-11
          • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,emydi, 10:43 AM, 03-11-11
            • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Tummy, 05:09 PM, 03-11-11
        • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,emydi, 10:41 AM, 03-11-11
  • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,cahaya, 08:30 PM, 03-10-11
    • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,zazzy, 10:25 AM, 03-11-11
      • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,cahaya, 11:42 AM, 03-11-11
        • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,emydi, 12:20 PM, 03-11-11
  • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Mom2JandA, 06:48 PM, 03-11-11
    • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,emydi, 10:24 AM, 03-14-11
  • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Tummy, 11:11 AM, 03-12-11
  • SLATES WIPED CLEAN CAN EDIT LISTS NO PENALTY,emydi, 10:28 AM, 03-15-11
    • RE: SLATES WIPED CLEAN CAN EDIT LISTS NO PENALTY,zazzy, 03:32 PM, 03-15-11
      • RE: SLATES WIPED CLEAN CAN EDIT LISTS NO PENALTY,emydi, 10:13 AM, 03-16-11
        • RE: SLATES WIPED CLEAN CAN EDIT LISTS NO PENALTY,csnumber23, 02:24 PM, 03-16-11
  • Updated Lists,mrc, 12:51 PM, 03-15-11
  • Belle's Updated List,Belle Book, 08:22 PM, 03-15-11
  • Clean Slate Lists,frodis, 06:56 AM, 03-16-11
  • Clean Slate,Snidget, 05:28 PM, 03-16-11
  • Corvis' New Picks,Corvis, 06:58 PM, 03-16-11
  • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Bob Loblaw, 11:52 PM, 03-16-11
    • RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS,Bob Loblaw, 11:59 AM, 05-14-11
Messages in this discussion
"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by emydi on 03-04-11 at 12:30 PM
LAST EDITED ON 03-11-11 AT 10:49 AM (EST)

WILL GO

12. Haley
11. Karen
10. Naima
9. Stefano
8. Thia
7. Jacob
6. Paul
5. Scotty
4. James
3. Pia
2. Lauren
1. Casey WINNER!

SHOULD GO

12. Stefano
11. Haley
10. Lauren
9. Paul
8. Pia
7. Jacob
6. Thia
5. Karen
4. Scotty
3. James
2. Naima
1. Casey WINNER!

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Tummy on 03-04-11 at 07:11 PM
I'm confused - yes, I know I've played before and even won - but are you saying Casey's going home first or winning in your Will Go list?
"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by cahaya on 03-04-11 at 07:56 PM
Based on the rankings she posted, I would guess she's got Casey winning it all.
"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Tummy on 03-04-11 at 08:05 PM
Well, that's just wrong. Everyone knows the winner goes on the bottom! And for us that are especially obtuse "- winner" is usually stated next to the name. ;)
"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by batts on 03-06-11 at 01:47 AM
LAST EDITED ON 03-06-11 AT 01:53 AM (EST)

I may play this year, I haven't decided yet.

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Belle Book on 03-05-11 at 09:50 PM
LAST EDITED ON 03-06-11 AT 01:14 PM (EST)

WILL GO:

13. Stefano Langone,
12. Ashton Jones,
11. Haley Reinhart,
10. Karen Rodriguez,
9. Paul McDonald,
8. Naima Adedapo,
7. Scotty McCreery,
6. Jacob Lusk,
5. James Durbin,
4. Pia Toscano,
3. Lauren Alaina Suddeth,
2. Casey Abrams
Winner. Thia Megia.

SHOULD GO:

13. Haley Reinhart,
12. Karen Rodriguez,
11. Paul McDonald,
10. Stefano Langone,
9. Ashton Jones,
8. Scotty McCreery,
7. Naima Adedapo,
6. Casey Abrams,
5. Jacob Lusk,
4. Lauren Alaina Suddeth,
3. James Durbin,
2. Pia Toscano
Winner. Thia Megia.


"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by emydi on 03-10-11 at 05:52 PM
Belle here's a little sumpin sumpin for you! thanks agman!


"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by cahaya on 03-06-11 at 12:33 PM
LAST EDITED ON 03-09-11 AT 06:40 PM (EST)

Will go

13. Ashthon Jones
12. Stefano Langone
11. Haley Reinhart
10. Naima Adedapo
9. Jacob Lusk
8. Karen Rodriguez
7. Paul McDonald
6. Thia Megia
5. Scotty McCreery
4. Pia Toscano
3. James Durbin
2. Lauren Alaina
1. Casey Abrams - winner

Should go

13. Ashthon Jones
12. Stefano Langone
11. Haley Reinhart
10. Paul McDonald
9. Karen Rodriguez
8. Scotty McCreery
7. Naima Adedapo
6. Lauren Alaina
5. Thia Megia
4. Jacob Lusk
3. Pia Toscano
2. James Durbin
1. Casey Abrams - winner

Editing just to add 'winner'. With all of the Casey picks here I was tempted to go with someone different, though!

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by djandy on 03-07-11 at 00:48 AM
LAST EDITED ON 03-12-11 AT 02:32 PM (EST)

Will Go:

13.) Ashton Jones
12.) Karen Rodriguez
11.) Haley Reinhart
10.) Stefano Langone
9.) Naima Adedapo
8.) Thia Megia
7.) Paul McDonald
6.) Lauren Alaina Suddeth
5.) Jacob Lusk
4.) Scotty McCreery
3.) James Durbin
2.) Casey Abrams
1.) Pia Toscano - Winner


Should Go:

13.) Ashton Jones
12.) Haley Reinhart
11.) Karen Rodriguez
10.) Naima Adedapo
9.) Stefano Langone
8.) Thia Megia
7.) Paul McDonald
6.) Lauren Alaina Suddeth
5.) Jacob Lusk
4.) Scotty McCreery
3.) Pia Toscano
2.) James Durbin
1.) Casey Abrams - Winner



"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Tummy on 03-07-11 at 05:43 PM
LAST EDITED ON 03-11-11 AT 05:12 PM (EST)


smooches to emy for hosting again AND for editing her PTTE.

Will

13. Ashthon - GONE
12. Stefano
11. Karen
10. Haley
9. Paul
8. Jacob
7. Thia
6. Naima
5. Scotty
4. Pia
3. James
2. Lauren Alaina
1. Casey - WINNER

Should

13. Ashthon
12. Stefano
11. Haley
10. Paul
9. Jacob
8. Karen
7. Pia
6. Thia
5. Scotty
4. Naima
3. James
2. Lauren Alaina
1. Casey - WINNER

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by batts on 03-08-11 at 05:22 AM
LAST EDITED ON 03-11-11 AT 10:17 PM (EST)

Oh, OK then... I'll play.

WILL GO

13 Ashton Jones is GONE
12 Haley Reinhart
11 Paul McDonald
10 Karen Rodriquez
9 Naima Adedapo
8 Stefano Langone
7 Thia Magia
6 Scotty McCreery
5 Jacob Lusk
4 Lauren Alaina Suddeth
3 Casey Abrams
2 James Durbin
1 Pia Toscano wins.

SHOULD GO

13 Ashton Jones is GONE
12 Haley Reinhart
11 Naima Adedapo
10 Paul McDonald
9 Scotty McCreery
8 Thia Magia
7 Lauren Alaina Suddeth
6 Karen Rodriguez
5 Jacob Lusk
4 Stefano Langone
3 Casey Abrams
2 Pia Toscano
1 James Durbin should win. heh heh heh...

Edited to take out Ashton Jones and to switch a couple since no penalty points this time.. like it'll do me any good.

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by csnumber23 on 03-08-11 at 09:22 AM
Will go

13 - Ashton Jones
12 - Naima Adedapo
11 - Stefano Langone
10 - Karen Rodriguez
9 - Paul Mcdonald
8 - Thia Megia
7 - Haley Reinhart
6 - Jacob Lusk
5 - Pia Toscano
4 - Scotty McCreery
3 - James Durbin
2 - Lauren Alaina (runner up)
1 - Casey Abrams (winner)

Should go

13 - Thia Megia
12 - Ashton Jones
11 - Stefano Langone
10 - Karen Rodriguez
9 - Naima Adedapo
8 - Paul Mcdonald
7 - Pia Toscano
6 - Haley Reinhart
5 - Jacob Lusk
4 - Scotty McCreery
3 - James Durbin
2 - Lauren Alaina (runner up)
1 - Casey Abrams (winner)

Is anyone doing an office poll this year? Was fun last year.

"I can start the funoffice pool, if that is the one you meant"
Posted by Snidget on 03-08-11 at 12:19 PM
• Pool Name: RTVW AI 10 Pool
• Password: RTVW
• Type: American Idol Pool - Top 13 Once the top 13 are announced, the pool begins. Get the amount of points you assign to a contestant if that contestant gets voted out. For the final week, you put your points on who you think will be the next American Idol.
• Description:
•
http://www.funofficepools.com/joinpool.php?Passed_Pool_Key=5a523e65e81

"RE: I can start the funoffice pool, if that is the one you meant"
Posted by emydi on 03-08-11 at 02:08 PM
thanks for doing this
"RE: I can start the funoffice pool, if that is the one you meant"
Posted by csnumber23 on 03-08-11 at 02:15 PM
Yeah, that's the one I meant. Thanks!
"RE: I can start the funoffice pool, if that is the one you meant"
Posted by cahaya on 03-09-11 at 06:38 PM
LAST EDITED ON 03-09-11 AT 06:38 PM (EST)

Thanks! I'm in!

I hope I remember to do this each week with all the various pools/picks I'm in, especially during March Madness.

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Snidget on 03-08-11 at 12:28 PM
Should Go

13 James Durbin
12 Lauren Alaina Suddeth
11 Stefano Langone
10 Ashton Jones
9 Paul McDonald
8 Pia Toscano
7 Scotty McCreery
6 Thia Megia
5 Haley Reinhart
4 Naima Adedap
3 Jacob Lusk
2 Karen Rodriguez
Winner Casey Abrams


Will Go

13 Ashton Jones
12 Naima Adedap
11 Karen Rodriguez
10 Jacob Lusk
9 Haley Reinhart
8 Stefano Langone
7 Pia Toscano
6 Scotty McCreery
5 Thia Megia
4 Paul McDonald
3 James Durbin
2 Lauren Alaina Suddeth
Winner Casey Abrams

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by mrc on 03-08-11 at 02:41 PM
Will go:

13. Thia Megia
12. Jacob Lusk
11. Stefano Langone
10. Lauren Alaina Suddeth
9. Paul McDonald
8. Naima Adedap
7. Pia Toscano
6. James Durbin
5. Karen Rodriguez
4. Ashton Jones
3. Scotty McCreery
2. Casey Abrams
1. Haley Reinhart

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by mrc on 03-08-11 at 02:42 PM
Should go:

13. Thia Megia
12. Jacob Lusk
11. Stefano Langone
10. Lauren Alaina Suddeth
9. Ashton Jones
8. Karen Rodriguez
7. Pia Toscano
6. James Durbin
5. Naima Adedap
4. Paul McDonald
3. Scotty McCreery
2. Casey Abrams
1. Haley Reinhart

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by mrc on 03-10-11 at 12:55 PM
I actually meant to flip Lauren and Haley in both lists. Oh well.
"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by zazzy on 03-08-11 at 06:58 PM
Will go:

1. Pia -- winner, AI 10
2. James
3. Lauren
4. Jacob
5. Casey
6. Scotty
7. Thia
8. Karen
9. Naima
10. Stefano
11. Paul
12. Haley
13. Ashton -- first to be booted

Should go:

1. Pia -- winner, AI 10
2. James
3. Lauren
4. Casey
5. Scotty
6. Jacob
7. Thia
8. Stefano
9. Naima
10. Karen
11. Paul
12. Haley
13. Ashton -- first to be booted

"Corvis' Picks"
Posted by Corvis on 03-09-11 at 06:27 PM
LAST EDITED ON 03-09-11 AT 06:33 PM (EST)

WILL GO:

13. Ashton Jones
12. Haley Reinhart
11. Stefano Langone
10. Paul McDonald
9. Naima Adedapo
8. Karen Rodriguez
7. Thia Megia
6. Jacob Lusk
5. Scotty McCreery
4. Lauren Alaina
3. Casey Abrams
2. James Durbin
1. Pia Toscano - WINNER

SHOULD GO:

13. Ashton Jones
12. Haley Reinhart
11. Stefano Langone
10. Jacob Lusk
9. Karen Rodriguez
8. Paul McDonald
7. Lauren Alaina
6. Naima Adedapo
5. Scotty McCreery
4. Casey Abrams
3. James Durbin
2. Pia Toscano
1. Thia Megia - WINNER

Remember her? *sigh*

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by frodis on 03-09-11 at 06:41 PM
Okay, I've never done a PTTE before so I'm jumping in!

WILL GO:
13. Ashthon Jones
12. Naima Adedap
11. Paul McDonald
10. Stefano Langone
09. Thia Megia
08. Karen Rodriguez
07. Haley Reinhart
06. James Durbin
05. Pia Toscano
04. Jacob Lusk
03. Casey Abrams
02. Lauren Alaina Suddeth
01. Scotty McCreery


SHOULD GO:
13. Ashthon Jones
12. Stefano Langone
11. Karen Rodriguez
10. Jacob Lusk
09. Haley Reinhart
08. James Durbin
07. Pia Toscano
06. Thia Megia
05. Paul McDonald
04. Naima Adedap
03. Lauren Alaina Suddeth
02. Casey Abrams
01. Scotty McCreery

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Bob Loblaw on 03-10-11 at 01:58 AM
LAST EDITED ON 03-10-11 AT 02:01 AM (EST)

Me, I've never thought it makes any sense to do your PTTE until you've heard the contestants do it for real in Week 1. Too much selective and uneven editing in the weeks leading up to the real thing.

Without further ado.....

WILL GO:

13. Ashthon
12. Stefano
11. Naima
10. Karen Rodriguez
9. Paul
8. Scotty
7. Jacob
6. Lauren
5. Haley
4. Thia
3. James
2. Pia
1. Casey ~ WinnerWinnerChickenDinner

SHOULD GO:

13. Ashthon
12. Naima
11. Stefano
10. Karen Rodriguez
9. Scotty
8. Jacob
7. Paul
6. Lauren
5. Haley
4. Thia
3. Pia
2. James
1. Casey ~ Winner

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Corvis on 03-10-11 at 08:43 PM
Um, dude...

"Get your lists in by Weds, March 9, 2010 8:00 EST. BEFORE THE SHOW STARTS"

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Bob Loblaw on 03-10-11 at 11:44 PM
I understand the rules, Corv, I just happen to disagree with that one. I feel the better test of one's prognostication abilities vis-a-vis AI is to wait until after the Week 1 performances and call your shot then.

I don't feel like we've had an equitable look into each final candidate's talent prior to that. Like, I couldn't tell you two things about Lauren Rodriguez before the week of the top 24. Maybe I just didn't pay enough attention early on, but I feel like I can't make a sound judgment, top to bottom, until I hear them do it for reals one good time. I'll take the four point penalty in order to have that opportunity....

It's worked out pretty well for me before....

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Tummy on 03-11-11 at 10:36 AM
Wednesday IS after you've heard them sing on Tuesday.

But I'm sure Emy will take your note into consideration and make appropriate changes. Or not.

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by emydi on 03-11-11 at 10:43 AM
psst...they sing on weds now...but see my post below....
"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Tummy on 03-11-11 at 05:09 PM
*snort

It's a good thing you're changing as I edited my list AFTER they sang. Not that I was trying to cheat, I just read your mind.

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by emydi on 03-11-11 at 10:41 AM
LAST EDITED ON 03-11-11 AT 10:50 AM (EST)

I was thinking about this before you posted when I saw that the Office Pool game was wiping the slate clean after week 1

The slates are wiped Clean!!

Please make your new Will GO and Should GO lists and take out Ashthon!

Any new players can also join with no Penalty...smidge you have to push the PTTE in the ECST!

But the new lists are due before the Top 12 sings on March 16, 2011 EDT *we lose an hour this weekend.

BTW, if you don't change your lists by next weds. I'll just take out Ashthon and renumber your lists accordingly.


"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by cahaya on 03-10-11 at 08:30 PM
Oh, hey, what's the rule on making changes again? As I recall, you pick up some penalty points... I forgot how many, though.
"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by zazzy on 03-11-11 at 10:25 AM
From Em's first post:

"You can change this list throughout the season but it will cost you +4 points each time you change your list (only one +4 penalty per week) "

Only the will go list can be changed.

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by cahaya on 03-11-11 at 11:42 AM
Hah! I feel like I just asked, "Pass the salt, please?", when the saltshaker is sitting right in front of me.

And not for the first time!

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by emydi on 03-11-11 at 12:20 PM
no penaltyt this week though

Slates wiped clean!

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Mom2JandA on 03-11-11 at 06:48 PM
LAST EDITED ON 03-11-11 AT 06:51 PM (EST)

Will Go:

12)Haley Reinhart
11)Karen Rodriguez
10)Naima Adedapo
9)Paul McDonald
8)Stefano Langone
7)Thia Megia
6)Jacob Lusk
5)Scotty McCreery
4)Lauren Alaina Suddeth
3)James Durbin
2)Pia Toscano
1)Casey Abrams- Winner

Should Go:

12)Karen Rodriguez
11)Naima Adedapo
10)Haley Reinhart
9)Paul McDonald
8)Scotty McCreery
7)Thia Megia
6)Stefano Langone
5)Jacob Lusk
4)Lauren Alaina Suddeth
3)James Durbin
2)Pia Toscano
1)Casey Abrams-Winner

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by emydi on 03-14-11 at 10:24 AM
Welcome Mom!! Thanks for playing and Good Luck!!!
"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Tummy on 03-12-11 at 11:11 AM
So as 99% of us have Casey as a winner, if he winds up leaving the competion due to health reasons do we get a free do-over? Because that will change everything.
"SLATES WIPED CLEAN CAN EDIT LISTS NO PENALTY"
Posted by emydi on 03-15-11 at 10:28 AM
I was thinking about this before you posted when I saw that the Office Pool game was wiping the slate clean after week 1

To make this stand out more...


The slates are wiped Clean!!

Please make your new Will GO and Should GO lists and take out Ashthon!

Any new players can also join with no Penalty...smidge you have to push the PTTE in the ECST!

But the new lists are due before the Top 12 sings on March 16, 2011 EDT *we lose an hour this weekend.

BTW, if you don't change your lists by next weds. I'll just take out Ashthon and renumber your lists accordingly.


"RE: SLATES WIPED CLEAN CAN EDIT LISTS NO PENALTY"
Posted by zazzy on 03-15-11 at 03:32 PM
Any incentive for keeping the list the same?
"RE: SLATES WIPED CLEAN CAN EDIT LISTS NO PENALTY"
Posted by emydi on 03-16-11 at 10:13 AM
nope...except your own satisfaction
"RE: SLATES WIPED CLEAN CAN EDIT LISTS NO PENALTY"
Posted by csnumber23 on 03-16-11 at 02:24 PM
Emydi, I will leave mine the same especially since my will go of Ashton was correct.
"Updated Lists"
Posted by mrc on 03-15-11 at 12:51 PM
Will Go:

12. Stefano
11. Thia
10. Haley
9. Naima
8. Paul
7. Jacob
6. Karen
5. Lauren
4. James
3. Scotty
2. Casey
1. Pia

Should Go:

12. Stefano
11. Naima
10. Jacob
9. Thia
8. Haley
7. Karen
6. Paul
5. James
4. Scotty
3. Lauren
2. Pia
1. Casey

A Slice of Manga

"Belle's Updated List"
Posted by Belle Book on 03-15-11 at 08:22 PM
LAST EDITED ON 03-16-11 AT 05:17 PM (EST)

Should:

12. Paul McDonald,
11. Karen Rodriguez,
10. Haley Reinhart,
9. Stefano Langone,
8. Jacob Lusk,
7. Naima Adedapo,
6. Scotty McCreery,
5. Casey Abrams,
4. Lauren Alaina Suddeth,
3. Pia Toscano,
2. James Durbin,
Winner. Thia Megia.

Will:

12. Casey Abrams (withdraws),
11. Karen Rodriguez,
10. Stefano Langone,
9. Haley Reinhart,
8. Paul McDonald,
7. Jacob Lusk,
6. Naima Adedapo,
5. Scotty McCreery,
4. Pia Toscano,
3. James Durbin,
2. Lauren Alaina Suddeth,
Winner. Thia Megia.

But if I'm wrong about Casey withdrawing:

12. Haley Reinhart,
11. Stefano Langone,
10. Karen Rodriguez,
9. Paul McDonald,
8. Jacob Lusk,
7. Naima Adedapo,
6. Casey Abrams,
5. Scotty McCreery,
4. Pia Toscano,
3. James Durbin,
2. Lauren Alaina Suddeth,
Winner. Thia Megia.


"Clean Slate Lists"
Posted by frodis on 03-16-11 at 06:56 AM
WILL GO:

12. Karen Rodriguez
11. Stefano Langone
10. Naima Adedap
09. Haley Reinhart
08. Paul McDonald
07. Thia Megia
06. Jacob Lusk
05. Lauren Alaina Suddeth
04. James Durbin
03. Pia Toscano
02. Casey Abrams
01. Scotty McCreery


SHOULD GO:

12. Stefano Langone
11. Karen Rodriguez
10. Jacob Lusk
09. Haley Reinhart
08. James Durbin
07. Pia Toscano
06. Thia Megia
05. Paul McDonald
04. Naima Adedap
03. Lauren Alaina Suddeth
02. Casey Abrams
01. Scotty McCreery

"Clean Slate"
Posted by Snidget on 03-16-11 at 05:28 PM
Should Go


12 James Durbin
11 Lauren Alaina Suddeth
10 Stefano Langone
9 Paul McDonald
8 Pia Toscano
7 Scotty McCreery
6 Thia Megia
5 Haley Reinhart
4 Naima Adedap
3 Jacob Lusk
2 Karen Rodriguez
Winner Casey Abrams


Will Go

13 Ashton Jones (sob...probably the only time I'll be right all season)
12 Stefano Langone
11 Karen Rodriguez
10 Jacob Lusk
9 Haley Reinhart
8 Naima Adedap
7 Pia Toscano
6 Scotty McCreery
5 Thia Megia
4 Paul McDonald
3 James Durbin
2 Lauren Alaina Suddeth
Winner Casey Abrams

"Corvis' New Picks"
Posted by Corvis on 03-16-11 at 06:58 PM
WILL GO:

13. Ashton Jones
12. Karen Rodriguez
11. Stefano Langone
10. Lauren Alaina
9. Naima Adedapo
8. Haley Reinhart
7. Paul McDonald
6. Jacob Lusk
5. Scotty McCreery
4. Thia Megia
3. Casey Abrams
2. James Durbin
1. Pia Toscano - WINNER

SHOULD GO:

13. Ashton Jones
12. Haley Reinhart
11. Stefano Langone
10. Jacob Lusk
9. Lauren Alaina
8. Karen Rodriguez
7. Paul McDonald
6. Naima Adedapo
5. Scotty McCreery
4. Casey Abrams
3. James Durbin
2. Pia Toscano
1. Thia Megia - WINNER

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Bob Loblaw on 03-16-11 at 11:52 PM
Glad you're doing the do-overs!

WILL GO:

12. Naima
11. Karen Rodriguez
10. Paul
9. Stefano
8. Haley
7. Jacob
6. Thia
5. Scotty
4. Lauren
3. James
2. Pia
1. Casey ~ WinnerWinnerChickenDinner

SHOULD GO:

12. Naima
11. Karen Rodriguez
10. Jacob
9. Stefano
8. Paul
7. Haley
6. Scotty
5. Lauren
4. Thia
3. Pia
2. James
1. Casey ~ Winner

"RE: AI10 PTTE WILL GO/SHOULD GO LISTS"
Posted by Bob Loblaw on 05-14-11 at 11:59 AM
*bump*