So who do you want in the finale? And who will America send home tonight.

Will we have sausage fest 3.0 or will a gril finally crack the top two after so long.

Should Go.

I'm giving a reason for each.

Casey--I'd hire him for lead guitar, this? is a singing competition
Crystal--While she wants the money, part of her really isn't keen on selling her soul.
Lee--why are they pimping the hades out of him? He isn't all that.

While losing Crystal would make all those "year of the gril" thing that much more amusing, I'm going with Casey going home. That wasn't a bus you heard warming it, it was a steam roller.

Will Go.

Casey.

Outside shot that Crystal will go, but I really wouldn't bet on that.

• RE: Top 3 Should Go/Will Go,geekboy, 08:41 AM, 05-19-10
  • RE: Top 3 Should Go/Will Go,mindy23, 09:57 AM, 05-19-10
• RE: Top 3 Should Go/Will Go,emydi, 10:36 AM, 05-19-10
• RE: Top 3 Should Go/Will Go,Belle Book, 04:52 PM, 05-19-10
• RE: Top 3 Should Go/Will Go,cahaya, 05:10 PM, 05-19-10
• RE: Top 3 Should Go/Will Go,zazzy, 05:56 PM, 05-19-10
  • RE: Top 3 Should Go/Will Go,cahaya, 07:01 PM, 05-19-10

This is a no-brainer, kids.

Crystal is in the final.
Lee is in the final
Casey is going home.
End of discussion.

Crystal and Lee deserve to be there. They have shown versatility, they have challenged themselves, and they have grown.

Casey, although I do believe he has it in him, has not shown much versatility at all and really hasn't grown since this started. Yes, he is killer on the guitar, but this is not Guitar Idol. Sadly, Casey has coasted through to the final three, and he blew it last night.

geekboy

"I think what Randy Travis was trying to say was 'What the hell was that?!'" - S. Cowell

Geekboy said most of what I would have. I am throwing my votes at Lee these days.

Started off a Crystal fan, but haven't seen the versatility in her that Lee has grown to show to us. She is great, amazing vocals, etc, etc. But as far as entertainment value, she doesn't have the charisma that Lee has shown to have. She'll have a career, for sure, ala, Carol King, Melissa Ethridge, Bonnie Raite, etc.

But people won't be flocking to watch her amazing performances the way they do for Cher, Tina Turner, and those women who KNOW how to hold an audience.

Lee, I believe, can be one of the greatest AI's to come out of this show, if he continues on. He has the makings of Daughtry, Cook, Hicks (personality-wise), and a few others who are still hanging out, making records. I think he's going to stick. He's adorable, those eyes can melt ice! And that smile-plus, his vocals, and personality remind me a bit of The Boss! Who better to represent AI than a former painter from the suburbs of Chicago??

Love him! Love Crystal, but she's only got a few tricks up the sleeve.

Casey? Without the guitar, he's another wabbler-beauty with not much singing ability. Could NOT listen to him for long at all....hopefully, America will get it right tonight.

Will Casey

Should Lee

Should and will go home: See ya later, Casey.

Should and will: Casey.

Should go: AI producers and judges

Will go: we all know the answer to this

Agree on the should part of that. What bothers me the most is that they blatantly favor one contestant over another, regardless of talent and performance, when it should be an even level playing field.