I feel if Jason would have proposed to Molly, he would have been having thoughts about Melissa....how would it have been with Melissa? Because he had dated two women at the same time, and thus fallen for them both...it would have been the same scenario with either woman. He would always have been wondering about the one that he didn't choose. I think that his gut instinct the first time was the right one, and he will live to regret it. In the first place, what girl in real life would date a man seriously that was also, seriously dating another woman? NONE! In the real world we call that a 'cheating heart'! On TV they call it, just the 'wrong choice.'

• RE: Cheatin' Heart,woiwod, 01:46 PM, 03-03-09

I don't think it would have been the same in reverse. There was always much more chemistry between him and Molly than with him and Melissa. I think he chose Melissa in the first place because he felt she needed him and having been through a divorce (as I have) a person needs to feel needed. None of us have any idea what happened with his first marriage but since he has custody I would suspect that she took off.