A) If they do this they oughta leave Stephenie and Bobby Jon out, since they both got to play twice already.

B) They just about have to at least offer Yau-Man a spot.

C) They have plenty of good ones to choose from. They need not use winners. Just imagine Ami and Twila from Vanuatu, or that cop lady or Gary from Guatemala? Lot of interesting possibilities.

Ha, I've seen people say "that cop lady from Guatemala" everywhere...haha nobodoy remembers her name

Or...wait! Maybe this is some sort of inside joke! uh oh....

LAST EDITED ON 05-30-07 AT 07:37 AM (EST)

>I don't know if this has
>been discussed in here yet,
>but I just read in
>this week's In Touch that
>there will be another All
>Stars edition after Survivor China
>airs. According to the
>article, it's for losers only,
>no winners can play.
>They will be from seasons
>9-15. It says their
>"wish list" includes Shane Powers,
>Cirie Fields, Jenn Lyon, Jeff
>Wilson, Ian Rosenberger, and Terry
>Dietz.
>
>Has anyone else heard about this?
>

OK...here is my 'wish' list 'Top 20' (including some previous winners)...leaving 2 spots open for China contestants:

Twila
Eliza (got to have the 'annoying' factor)
Ami
Chris
Ian
Tom
Judd
Amy
Terry
Shane
Courtney (got to have the 'annoying' factor...Take '2')
Cirie
Yul
Ozzie
Rocky
Dreamz
Yau-Man
Lisi

That leaves 2 spots for women of 'China' Season...the women are harder to pick than the guys.
Enough of Stephanie & Bobby-Jon...2 shots..more than anyone else!
I'm sure Jenn form Palau will be picked for the story line of surviving cancer but she was boring to watch & should not be on All-Stars...but then again all I have to say is Amber, Shi-Ann & Alicia...hmmm!

Jeff Wilson and Jen Lyon? Please, I didn't even remember who those people were. I had to look them up. Jeff I believe was the guy from Palua who got injured...I at least remember something about him. Jen Lyon?? I could not remember anything about her...her face looks somewhat familiar like I may of gone to high school with her or something.....I would not recignize her walking down the street at all. You can not have poeple like this on all-stars.

If it means casting Stephanie and Bobby Jon...or previous winners lets do that. We need memorable people. All-Star should be ALL STARS! For once can we just see the very best players. If it means casting Stephanie and Bobby Jon on a team of winner.....not that they were winners but the team of winners would not hold prejudice against them.

You know what would be funny. Let's have two teams. CBS should name the teams for them. One team simply called WINNERS. The other team simply called LOSERS. These teams will hate each other. WINNERS will get all arrogant thinking they are better than the losers and the losers will hate the other team simply because they are called winners and have won. Could even give the winners a luxury camp. Add all that in and watch these two team go cut throat.

I for one want to see a real team of All Stars for once. No stunt casting.

I for one want to see a real team of All Stars for once. No stunt casting.

You might be surprised at how hard that can be. I cast winners, a Pearl Islander, and four fictional Survivors, and I still had trouble getting it up to 20. Check out my stroy and see how I did...and how hard it can be to cast with such strict requirements.

I can say this much: In my version of All-Stars, people like Dreamz were unnecessary. To EPMB, he's a must.

At least Dreamz made it to the final three. But let me choose between Earl and Dreams (same demographic) I would take Earl in a heartbeat. Shii Ann was the perfect exaple in the first all stars. She was a lame player one never could not stand the first time around but because she fit a demogrpahic she was cast for all stars even though nothing she did shined of all-star.

Shii Ann was the perfect exaple in the first all stars. She was a lame player one never could not stand the first time around but because she fit a demogrpahic she was cast for all stars even though nothing she did shined of all-star.

I'm not sure which demographic she fit...wither a young Asian female or a Thailand castaway...I'm of the opinion she was cast because Brian turned them down and they needed someone out of Thailand.

Frankly, Brian would have made a better replacement for Lex, Sandra would have made a better replacement for Shii Ann (though I realize she was still recovering from illness,) and then an entire tribe could have been composed of winners. I suppose they could have asked Vecepia to replace Jenna in that case, but that might have been a WTF moment all in its own.