URL: http://community.realitytvworld.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/rtvw2/community/dcboard.cgi
Forum: DCForumID4
Thread Number: 4015
[ Go back to previous page ]

Original Message
"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"

Posted by Colonel Zoidberg on 03-27-06 at 07:39 PM
This season is the fifth, of course - Thailand. The rules are the same as always: Give a grade A through F. Plusses and minusesd are allowed, but A+, F+, and F- will not be recorded; they will be A, F, and F, respectively.

So without further ado, here it is:

SOOK JAI TRIBE

Jake Billingsley
Erin Collins
Stephanie Dill
Jed Hildebrand
Shii Ann Huang
Penny Ramsey
Ken Stafford
Robb Zbacnik

CHUAY GAHN TRIBE

Jan Gentry
Helen Glover
Ghandia Johnson
Clay Jordan
Brian Heidik
John Raymond
Ted Rogers
Tanya Vance


Table of contents

Messages in this discussion
"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by MacabreMasquerade on 03-27-06 at 08:09 PM
SOOK JAI TRIBE

Jake Billingsley: F
Erin Collins: F
Stephanie Dill: F
Jed Hildebrand: F
Shii Ann Huang: A
Penny Ramsey: F
Ken Stafford: F
Robb Zbacnik: F

CHUAY GAHN TRIBE

Jan Gentry: F
Helen Glover: B
Ghandia Johnson: F
Clay Jordan: F
Brian Heidik: A
John Raymond: F
Ted Rogers: F
Tanya Vance: F




"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by KObrien_fan on 03-27-06 at 08:47 PM
SOOK JAI TRIBE

Jake Billingsley A+
Erin Collins C
Stephanie Dill D
Jed Hildebrand F
Shii Ann Huang C
Penny Ramsey B
Ken Stafford B
Robb Zbacnik C

CHUAY GAHN TRIBE

Jan Gentry D
Helen Glover C
Ghandia Johnson F--
Clay Jordan D
Brian Heidik A
John Raymond C
Ted Rogers B
Tanya Vance F



"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by xwraith27 on 03-27-06 at 08:51 PM
LAST EDITED ON 03-27-06 AT 08:53 PM (EST)

SOOK JAI TRIBE

Jake Billingsley D
Erin Collins D
Stephanie Dill D
Jed Hildebrand D
Shii Ann Huang C-
Penny Ramsey C
Ken Stafford B
Robb Zbacnik B-

CHUAY GAHN TRIBE

Jan Gentry D
Helen Glover B+
Ghandia Johnson F
Clay Jordan C-
Brian Heidik A
John Raymond F
Ted Rogers C
Tanya Vance D


"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by byoffer on 03-27-06 at 10:00 PM
SOOK JAI TRIBE

Jake Billingsley C
Erin Collins C
Stephanie Dill F
Jed Hildebrand F
Shii Ann Huang D
Penny Ramsey C
Ken Stafford C
Robb Zbacnik D

CHUAY GAHN TRIBE

Jan Gentry B
Helen Glover B
Ghandia Johnson D
Clay Jordan B
Brian Heidik A
John Raymond F
Ted Rogers C
Tanya Vance F



"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by southpaw on 03-27-06 at 10:03 PM
SOOK JAI TRIBE

Jake Billingsley: B
Erin Collins: D-
Stephanie Dill: F
Jed Hildebrand: F
Shii Ann Huang: A
Penny Ramsey: B-
Ken Stafford: C+
Robb Zbacnik: D

CHUAY GAHN TRIBE

Jan Gentry: C
Helen Glover: B+
Ghandia Johnson: F
Clay Jordan: D+
Brian Heidik: A-
John Raymond: F
Ted Rogers: C-
Tanya Vance :F


"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by taffnic on 03-28-06 at 00:33 AM
SOOK JAI TRIBE

Jake Billingsley-B-
Erin Collins-C
Stephanie Dill-D+
Jed Hildebrand-D
Shii Ann Huang-A
Penny Ramsey-B-
Ken Stafford-C
Robb Zbacnik-D

CHUAY GAHN TRIBE

Jan Gentry-D
Helen Glover-B
Ghandia Johnson-F
Clay Jordan-D
Brian Heidik-A-
John Raymond-F
Ted Rogers-B
Tanya Vance -C


"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by tribephyl on 03-28-06 at 04:54 AM
SOOK JAI TRIBE

Jake Billingsley ~ A
Erin Collins ~ C
Stephanie Dill ~ A
Jed Hildebrand ~ A
Shii Ann Huang ~ B
Penny Ramsey ~ D
Ken Stafford ~ A
Robb Zbacnik ~ C

CHUAY GAHN TRIBE

Jan Gentry ~ B
Helen Glover ~ B
Ghandia Johnson ~ F
Clay Jordan ~ F
Brian Heidik ~ D
John Raymond ~ C
Ted Rogers ~ F
Tanya Vance ~ C


"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by Aruba on 03-28-06 at 06:39 AM
SOOK JAI TRIBE

JAKE (C-) - Started out liking this guy until he began telling his Davy Crockett stories. I was waiting patiently for him to tell us that he "was born on a mountaintop in Tennessee" and that he "killed a bear when he was only three..."

ERIN (B) - IMO the hottest Survivor chick ever. But will never be considered for that honor because she was clever enough to cover up knowing she would advance further that way. Not only hott; but smart!

STEPHANIE (F) - Forgot who she was???

JED (C-) - When your own tribe throws a challenge to boot you off that's not a good thing.

SHII ANN (B+) - Other than Brian, only one this season who really knew how to play this game. Was too smart for her own good this season, but All-Stars was more her forum to shine.

PENNY (C) - Coattail rider; UTR; need I say more?

KEN (B-) - Hard not to like this NYC cop fresh off the 9-11 tradegy. But how could he lose an immunity challenge to Clay heads-up?

ROBB (F) - Eligibility rule is you must be 21. Too bad that doesn't refer to maturity level; otherwise he would have stayed home where he belonged.


CHUAY GAHN

JAN (C-) - Never has a F3 Survivor been so clueless on how to play the game.

HELEN (C+) - I liked her alot until she became a part of the ever-growing Survivor fraternity of Sore Losers. Hence she dropped a bit as a result.

GHANDIA (F) - She was just as much into the cuddling as Ted; then the next morning you would have thought that he raped her? What a jerk. And the way she carried on...What a baby!

CLAY (B) - Doesn't get as much credit as he deserves because of his annoying behavior. But knew what he had to do to advance and was very clever to associate with the Sook Jai members knowing they would constitute most of the jury. As a result almost pulled off the greatest upset in Survivor history.

BRIAN (A) - The dominant Survivor this season was clearly a cut above everyone else and deserved the victory.

JOHN (D) - Preacher man didn't have enough time to give us a sermon. Never understood why he was the first boot, but must have been some reason.

TED (B) - Strong force in the challenges. Getting drunk at a reward challenge was one of the highlights of this season.

TANYA (F) - Who was she?


"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by michel on 03-28-06 at 09:30 AM
LAST EDITED ON 03-28-06 AT 09:32 AM (EST)

The worst season ever. Minor league level cast. Brian played well but had no opposition:

Sook Jay:

Jake Billingsley: (C) Needed to assert himself more. He let Penny decide.

Erin Collins: (D) Did nothing.

Stephanie Dill: (F) clueless follower of Jed???

Jed Hildebrand: (D) He didn't know what to do

Shii Ann Huang: (D) very over-rated player. She really never did anything in 2 seasons. Never did she lead and couldn't follow. That is the worst way to play survivor.

Penny Ramsey: (B) The only smart player in this tribe. She had Jake wrapped around her little finger, knew he controlled Ken who had influence on Robbbbb. She also had Erin's vote. It would've been interesting to see her perform if Sook Jay got to the merge ahead.

Ken Stafford: (D) A strong guy like him chose to follow which is going against his character. He could've taken leadership and then his tribe would've been solid.

Robbbbb Zbbbacnik: (FFFF) Having to many B's in his name, bringing a skateboard to the beach (!?) and having a mental breakdown, that's all I remember of him.


Chuay Gahn

Jan Gentry: (F) She gave the money to Brian.

Helen Glover: (C) She gave the money to Brian.

Ghandia Johnson: (F)

Clay Jordan: (C) as Richard invented a way to win, he invented a way to finish second. $100 000 isn't bad for doing nothing.

Brian Heidik: (B) Always knew what to do. Too bad he wasn't challenged. He was bored with the game and was boring to watch.

John Raymond: (D) Never really knew him, but wasn't following Brian so he had to go.

Ted Rogers: (C) Strong player who had no chance of winning after the Ghandia incident.

Tanya Vance: (D) didn't follow Brian , did nothing to oppose him.



"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by CattyChat on 03-28-06 at 12:15 PM
My most hated season. I will never buy this season on DVD to add to my Survivor library!

SOOK JAI TRIBE
Jake Billingsley --------D+
Erin Collins -----------D-
Stephanie Dill---------D
Jed Hildebrand--------C
Shii Ann Huang ------- B+
Penny Ramsey --------F
Ken Stafford --------- D+
Robb Zbacnik ---------F

CHUAY GAHN TRIBE
Jan Gentry ---------D
Helen Glover ------ C-
Ghandia Johnson ----F
Clay Jordan --------F
Brian Heidik --------F
John Raymond ------D-
Ted Rogers---------C-
Tanya Vance--------D


Kind Creation of ARNutz


"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by ivoryElephant on 03-28-06 at 07:17 PM
SOOK JAI TRIBE

Jake Billingsley B
Erin Collins C
Stephanie Dill D
Jed Hildebrand D
Shii Ann Huang C
Penny Ramsey C
Ken Stafford F
Robb Zbacnik F

CHUAY GAHN TRIBE

Jan Gentry F
Helen Glover A
Ghandia Johnson F
Clay Jordan B
Brian Heidik A
John Raymond D
Ted Rogers C
Tanya Vance C

mind the gap


"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by agressionx on 03-29-06 at 03:19 PM
SOOK JAI TRIBE

Jake Billingsley: B-
Erin Collins: D
Stephanie Dill: D+
Jed Hildebrand: F
Shii Ann Huang: A
Penny Ramsey: C
Ken Stafford: C
Robb Zbacnik: D+

CHUAY GAHN TRIBE

Jan Gentry: D
Helen Glover: C-
Ghandia Johnson: D-
Clay Jordan: C+
Brian Heidik: B-
John Raymond: F
Ted Rogers: C
Tanya Vance : D


"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by FWG on 03-30-06 at 01:50 AM
SOOK JAI TRIBE

Jake Billingsley - A-
Erin Collins - D
Stephanie Dill - D
Jed Hildebrand - D
Shii Ann Huang - B
Penny Ramsey - C
Ken Stafford - D
Robb Zbacnik - C-

CHUAY GAHN TRIBE

Jan Gentry - F
Helen Glover - B-
Ghandia Johnson - F (unless I can give her a G)
Clay Jordan - C
Brian Heidik - B+
John Raymond - D-
Ted Rogers - D
Tanya Vance - D-


On the whole, easily my least favorite cast of all time.


"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by 321Jump on 03-30-06 at 05:15 PM
SOOK JAI TRIBE

Jake Billingsley - B
Erin Collins - C
Stephanie Dill - D
Jed Hildebrand - F
Shii Ann Huang - C
Penny Ramsey - C
Ken Stafford - C
Robb Zbacnik - D

CHUAY GAHN TRIBE

Jan Gentry - C
Helen Glover - B
Ghandia Johnson - F
Clay Jordan - B
Brian Heidik - A
John Raymond - D
Ted Rogers - B
Tanya Vance - C


"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by smokedog on 03-30-06 at 05:58 PM
>SOOK JAI TRIBE
>
>Jake Billingsley C
>Erin Collins C
>Stephanie Dill D
>Jed Hildebrand D
>Shii Ann Huang C
>Penny Ramsey C
>Ken Stafford B
>Robb Zbacnik F
>
>CHUAY GAHN TRIBE
>
>Jan Gentry F
>Helen Glover C
>Ghandia Johnson F
>Clay Jordan C
>Brian Heidik A
>John Raymond F
>Ted Rogers B
>Tanya Vance A




"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by gizmo_ber on 03-30-06 at 07:27 PM
SOOK JAI TRIBE

Jake Billingsley- C-
Erin Collins- F
Stephanie Dill- C-
Jed Hildebrand- C+
Shii Ann Huang- C+
Penny Ramsey- C
Ken Stafford- C
Robb Zbacnik- D

CHUAY GAHN TRIBE

Jan Gentry- D-
Helen Glover- D
Ghandia Johnson- D-
Clay Jordan- D
Brian Heidik- A-
John Raymond- C
Ted Rogers- C+
Tanya Vance- D


don't like sunlight, keep me away from water, don't feed me after midnight


"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by rjac21 on 03-30-06 at 10:44 PM
SOOK JAI TRIBE

Jake Billingsley - A-
Erin Collins - A
Stephanie Dill - C
Jed Hildebrand - C+
Shii Ann Huang - B
Penny Ramsey - C+
Ken Stafford - A-
Robb Zbacnik - B+

CHUAY GAHN TRIBE

Jan Gentry - B+
Helen Glover - B+
Ghandia Johnson - FFFFFFFFF
Clay Jordan - C-
Brian Heidik - A
John Raymond - C-
Ted Rogers - D
Tanya Vance - B


"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by dreamerbeliever on 03-31-06 at 01:24 AM
SOOK JAI TRIBE

Jake Billingsley A
Erin Collins A
Stephanie Dill D+
Jed Hildebrand D
Shii Ann Huang F
Penny Ramsey C+
Ken Stafford B+
Robb Zbacnik B

CHUAY GAHN TRIBE

Jan Gentry C-
Helen Glover C+
Ghandia Johnson F
Clay Jordan D
Brian Heidik B+
John Raymond D-
Ted Rogers C
Tanya Vance B



"RE: Survivor: Ultimate Tournament - Round 5"
Posted by Colonel Zoidberg on 04-03-06 at 08:54 PM
SOOK JAI TRIBE

Jake Billingsley - B+
Erin Collins - C
Stephanie Dill - D
Jed Hildebrand - D-
Shii Ann Huang - C+
Penny Ramsey - C-
Ken Stafford - C+
Robb Zbacnik - C-

CHUAY GAHN TRIBE

Jan Gentry - C
Helen Glover - C+
Ghandia Johnson - F
Clay Jordan - C
Brian Heidik - A
John Raymond - D-
Ted Rogers - C+
Tanya Vance - D+