URL: http://community.realitytvworld.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/rtvw2/community/dcboard.cgi
Forum: DCForumID4
Thread Number: 2476
[ Go back to previous page ]
Original Message
"##### PART DEUX"
Posted by MikeD on 04-26-04 at 04:02 PM
Without using the current roster, who all would you cast in a Survivor All-Stars 2?

I would think it would be interesting to cast all the first, second and third boots off of every season?

Table of contents
Messages in this discussion
"RE: ##### PART DEUX"
Posted by KObrien_fan on 04-26-04 at 04:34 PM
Nobody from the current roster, but going with same 3 tribe format=

Tribe 1-
Roger Sexton
Ryan Oprey
Sean Rector
Ramona Gray
Erin Collins
Zoe Zandackis

Tribe 2-
Gervase Peterson
Jon Dalton
Matthew Von Ertfelda
Stephanie Dill
Kelly Goldsmith
Maralyn Hershey

Tribe 3-
Carl Bilancione
Hunter Ellis
Dave Johnson
Tammy Leitner
Tijuana Bradley
Gretchen Cordy

"RE: ##### PART DEUX"
Posted by silentJ on 04-27-04 at 02:27 AM
T1
Sandra
Gervase
Pascal
Heidi
Sean Rector
Erin

T2
Vecepia
Helen
Flamin' Mike
Jon
Christy
Silas

T3
Brian
Lillian
Gretchen
John Carrol
Keith
Gina

(Erin, Silas, Gina, and Keith could easily be dumped to make way for new stars. Please God, let Survivor start soon.)

"RE: ##### PART DEUX"
Posted by Kokoro on 04-27-04 at 08:01 AM
LAST EDITED ON 04-27-04 AT 08:07 AM (EST)

I'm not sure All-Stars turned out to be such a good idea in the first place, but if they did another one it would have to be all out - the cast would be comprised almost entirely of the most strategical or abrasive players, with a few sweeter favourites thrown in for balance. At least then we'd for sure have entertainment.

Ideally:

S1: Kelly Wiglesworth, Colleen Haskell, Greg Buis
S2: Elisabeth Filarski, Rodger Bingham, Jeff Varner
S3: Brandon Quinton, Kelly Goldsmith
S4: Vecepia Towery, Sean Rector
S5: Brian Heidik, Clay Jordan, Helen Glover
S6: Matthew Von Ertfelda, Heidi Strobel, Deena Bennett
S7: Sandra Diaz-Twine, Jon Dalton

No Jennases, Ambers, Alicias, Ethans, Shii Anns or Ruperts to be spoken of (Yes Vee sucks as a character, but she knows what she's doing as a player). This show would totally rock.

"RE: ##### PART DEUX"
Posted by Tinman on 04-27-04 at 09:49 AM
What, no Ghandia?? <eyes rolling> I'm shocked!
"RE: ##### PART DEUX"
Posted by tribephyl on 05-02-04 at 01:33 AM
What, no Ghandia?? <eyes rolling> I'm shocked!

If Ghandia were invited back, we might have to change the title to ASS Deux-Deux

Get it?


All-Stars my ASS!!!!

"RE: ##### PART DEUX"
Posted by dabo on 05-01-04 at 10:25 PM
LAST EDITED ON 05-01-04 AT 10:27 PM (EST)

Tough assignment, Mike, but I finally got both my cast and the tribes figured out for Survivor Second-Chance. Let's see what you think.

Tribe 1
Andrew (7)
Deena (6)
Jake (5)
Kelly (1)
Michael (2)
Tammy (4)

Tribe 2
Frank (3)
Helen (5)
Jeff (2)
John (4)
Shawna (6)
Tijuana (7)

Tribe 3
Gervace (1)
Kimmi (2)
Matthew (6)
Ryan S. (7)
Stephanie (5)
Teresa (3)

Tribe 4
Dave (6)
Hunter (4)
Kel (2)
Kim P. (3)
Ramona (1)
Tania (5)

Big twist #1: for the first several episode Tribes 1 and 2 compete against each other with no knowledge of Tribes 3 and 4, and Tribes 3 and 4 compete against each other with no knowledge of Tribes 1 and 2.

SMILES ARE FREE

"RE: ##### PART DEUX"
Posted by smokedog on 05-01-04 at 11:58 PM
No repeats - but I am going to add people who would have been in the 1st A$$ and turned it down.

9 guys
s1 Gervase
s2 Michael (screwed by fire)
s3 Silas (screwed by the twist)
s4 John
s4 Sean
s4 Paschal (screwed by the purple rock)
s5 Brian (winner)
s5 Clay
s7 Jonny Fairplay

9 gals
s1 Kelly
s1 Colleen
s2 Elisabeth
s3 Kelly
s4 Tammy
s4 Vecepia (winner)
s5 Helen
s6 Heidi
s7 Sandra (winner)

"RE: ##### PART DEUX"
Posted by Survivorerist on 05-02-04 at 11:34 PM
Are we just picking favourites? Okay then...

Tribe 1

Neleh Dennis
Stephanie Dill
Kelly Goldsmith
Sean Rector
Rodger Bingham
Andrew Savage

Tribe 2

Zoe Zanidakis
Sandra Diaz-Twine
Sonja Christopher
Brian Heidik
Dave Johnson
Brandon Quinton

Tribe 3

Gretchen Cordy
Heidi Strobel
Elisabeth Filarski
John Carroll
Gervase Peterson
Jeff Varner


"I'll need a big spoon because I have a big mouth."

"RE: ##### PART DEUX"
Posted by Jims02 on 05-03-04 at 00:50 AM
LAST EDITED ON 05-03-04 AT 00:51 AM (EST)

Men
Brian
Jeff
Michael
Jonny Fairplay
Paschal
Jake
Burton
John C.
Dave (obligatory S6 person)

Women
Sandra
Vecepia
Kelly G.
Gina
Christa
Helen
Kelly W.
Gretchen
Teresa

S1: 2
S2: 2
S3: 2
S4: 4
S5: 3
S6: 1
S7: 4

That's just off the top of my head.


Jims02: 2004 CMY Anti-Executee Champ

"RE: ##### PART DEUX"
Posted by airwolves on 05-05-04 at 02:16 AM
First of all, let me say this, Survivor: All Stars was a little messed up. Although, I loved it because I am a diehard Survivor fan. But it wasn't All Stars. They should have picked only people who finished in the top 4, or maybe the top 6. Not all over the map. The better a survivor finished the first time, the bigger target they are on All Stars. My version would have no-one from the top 4 of any Survivor, and picked on Popularity, Game play, Strategy, & Most Deserving of a second chance ("I was robbed"). And Survivor Part Deux is a good name.

My Picks for Survior: Part Deux-

Women:

S1 COLLEN HASKELL 6th place
S1 RAMONA GRAY 13th place
S2 KIMMI KAPPENBERG 12th place
S3 JESSIE CAMACHO 15th place
S3 LINDA SPENCER 13th place
S4 SARAH JONES 13th place
S5 ERIN COLLINS 9th place
S6 DEENA BENNET 8th place
S7 NICOLE DELMA 16th place


Men:

S1 GERVASE PETERSON 7th place
S2 MICHAEL SKULPIN 11th place
S2 JEFF VARNER 10th place
S3 FRANK GARRISON 7th place
S4 ROBERT (THE GENERAL) DECANIO 6th place
S4 HUNTER ELLIS 14th place
S5 JAKE BILLINGSLEY 6th place
S6 ALEX BELL 7th place
S7 ANDREW SAVAGE 8th place


All Survior Shows are represented.

S1-3, S2-3, S3-3, S4-3, S5-2, S6-2, S7-2
With no one finishing aboce 6th place. Harder to target that way