I would have like to see JOHNNY FAIRPLAY, I cant believe they didnt put the biggest villain in there. Love him or hate him he was a STAR, and had the personality that would have been fun.

Also I think Brian the used car salesman, was another strong castaway, that should have been on there. The man won, he should have been an all star.

Jeff from the outback. I think that was his name anyway.

thos are 3 I would like to have seen.

• RE: So who didnt make the ASS cut you would have like to see???,Milan23, 08:59 PM, 02-01-04
  • RE: So who didnt make the ASS cut you would have like to see???,Jedidog, 12:39 PM, 02-02-04
  • Right on the money,arturbars, 12:49 PM, 02-02-04
    • I like yours arturbars,Wacko Jacko, 07:40 PM, 02-02-04
• RE: So who didnt make the ASS cut you would have like to see???,theking0075, 05:01 PM, 02-02-04
• RE: So who didnt make the ASS cut you would have like to see???,Howard Dean, 06:08 PM, 02-02-04
• RE: So who didnt make the ASS cut you would have like to see???,RealityRyan, 07:48 PM, 02-02-04
  • RE: So who didnt make the ASS cut you would have like to see???,Howard Dean, 00:30 AM, 02-03-04
• RE: So who didnt make the ASS cut you would have like to see???,shanana banana, 03:03 PM, 02-03-04
  • RE: So who didnt make the ASS cut you would have like to see???,leogirl_21, 08:36 AM, 02-04-04
    • RE: So who didnt make the ASS cut you would have like to see???,Howard Dean, 02:07 PM, 02-05-04
• The true hardcores...Brian and Mike Scupin,ASS_Man, 04:21 PM, 02-05-04
• RE: So who didnt make the ASS cut you would have like to see???,PhoenixMons, 04:42 PM, 02-05-04
• RE: So who didnt make the ASS cut you would have like to see???,Sagebrush Dan, 06:36 PM, 02-07-04

I would have liked to see Jeff Varner only because he's so delightfully bitchy, not because I think he really deserves a spot. I'm amazed that Mike Skupkin didn't make the cut...not necessarily my favorite, but he did make great tv.

Out of all the All -Stars, I think these guys should have been involved:

1) Elisabeth Filarksi - America's sweetheart and STILL the best looking woman to ever play the game. She just had a great personality and played the game with so much spirit.. I really wish she had been able to postpone "The View"
2) Jonny Fairplay - DEFINITELY would have made things a bit more interesting. I would have loved to see him on the Chapera tribe with the other devious schemers Rob C. and Rob M. He will be missed.
3) Heidi Strobel - the woman that men love and women love to hate. Heidi should have made it to ASS just for her stupid and shallow comments that leave you shaking your head. Did she really just say that?? She is the mean spirited Jessia Simpson.

Honorable Mention - Sean Rector. What show does need an angry, black man to stir up trouble?

Elisabeth could have replaced lame-o Amber.
Heidi could have gotten rid of Jenna Lewis
and Jonny could have replaced a lovable but senile Rudy.

All these personalities would have made a GREAT show,even better.

between you two, you named some people who really should be there:

Johny Fairplay and Michael Skupin - both would be great on ASS!

But it would be hard to get rid of any male all-stars who already on the show - they all are great too.

I still think that they should have went with 24 people instead of 18 (three tribes of 8 instead of 6).

Some othe possible allstars could have been:

Helen - thailand
Matt (crazy matteo) - amazaon
Sean R - marquesas
Gina - marquesas
Gerverse (spellin?) - Borneo
Brian - thailand
Sandra - pearl islands

I also think Jake would've been good. If he were on a different tribe I think he would of done much better. he tried really hard but 'brians' tribe would have nothing to do with it.

I think Thailand got screwed.

I also like Robb, would like to see if the survivor experience really changed him.

How Shii Ann became the rep is beyond me.

The top two for me though are mike Skupin and Jonny fairplay.

I liked Matt too.

Didn't watch the first Survivor but Gervase seemed to have some personality.

If they could have brought back Kelly and put her in the same tribe as Susan and Richard, that would have been awesome!

"Evil" Dr. Will: Reality Show Legend!

I liked all of the players Mark Burnett chose, but it would have been fun to see some of the "supporting" players too.

These players may not dominate the game like a Richard, Lex, Tina or Colby, but they definitely make the game more interesting.

Borneo

Gervase
Coleen (declined invitation)
Greg

Australia

Jeff
Michael
Elizabeth (declined invitation)
Rodger

Africa

Kelly
Brandon
Teresa
Clarence

Marquesas

Gina
Hunter
Sean

Thailand

Clay
Erin
Ken

Amazon

Dave
Heidi
Jeanne

Pearl Islands

Sandra
Jon
Andrew

To accomodate more players, I would have 4 tribes, 8 people each, for a total of 32 players. Of course that would also have meant that they'd need to boot 2 players each week, but it would have been worth it.

Would CBS pay for it? Probably not, but it would have been fun.

I like the 3 tribes of 8 idea as well, so I would add:

Sandra
Deena
Helen

Gervase
Johnny Fairplay
John from Marquesis

Kathy must win !!! Down with THE RUPERT!
I heart America's Next Top Model

Lex must win! Or Colby! Forget Kathy! lol

>Kathy must win
>!!! Down with THE
>RUPERT!
>I heart America's Next Top
>Model

Johnny Fairplay. I started out hating him, I ended up loving him. That's the mark of a great Survivor player.

Who's Johnny Fairplay? Sorry, I don't know...

Don't let your fears stand in the way of your dreams.

The mind is not a vessel to be filled but a fire to be ignited. - Plutarch

He's the one with the lie about his grandmother in Survivor 7 just shown a couple of months ago.

>Who's Johnny Fairplay? Sorry, I don't
>know...
>

(MEN)
Brian: What can you say about the guy...rocked the challenges...and he's a porn stAr

Mike Scupin: This man killed a pig...what else do i need to say

Clay: Dumb Redneck factor Squared

(WOMEN)
Heidi - perfect pairing for Lamber...Dumb and Dumb (and great rack)

Gina - Nice Eye Candy...she would be strong too

Adding one more of each (m/f) to each tribe to make 3 teams of 8...

Sean R. (the most obvious choice and I still can't believe he wasn't included)
Mike S. (another obvious choice)
if there weren't already three from Africa, I'd have liked to see Brandon again, but Jon from S7 or Gervase from S1

Helen - was one of the few interesting folks on that horrendous cast
Sandra (S7) - I know she declined, but I'd have loved to see her out there again despite the fact that I think All Stars shouldn't be called All-Stars (rather Second Chance Survivor or something like that) and shouldn't include winners ;)
Kelly W. (S1) - she should be there, too

I would also like to remove Amber, who has no business being on All-Stars, and Rob M. (simply to make room for the much better male representative of S4 - Sean R.)

My cast (as I've put together for these little lists before) would have been much more entertaining than MB's!

I wouldn't be surprised if MB brougth in Jon as one of those "surprise twists" they keep talking about.

Too bad Colleen declined.