URL: http://community.realitytvworld.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/rtvw2/community/dcboard.cgi
Forum: DCForumID4
Thread Number: 1988
[ Go back to previous page ]
Original Message
"Survivor 7 What if?"
Posted by ivoryElephant on 11-02-03 at 05:12 PM
We had survivor whatif for S1-6 and now it is time for us to decide who we think should win S7.

If you don't know the rules, here they are: For each round we decide who we think should have been voted off.

We can also vote for who wins the next IC... since Morgan went to TC first we will vote out one of them....

Morgan at TC

Osten
Andrew
Ryan O.
Ryan S.
Nicole
Darrah
Tijuana
Lillian

Table of contents
Messages in this discussion
"Nicole"
Posted by LozengeofLove on 11-02-03 at 05:44 PM
LAST EDITED ON 11-02-03 AT 08:49 PM (EST)

She had a horrible strategy, if there was one at all.

EDIT: Drake wins next IC

"RE: Survivor 7 What if?"
Posted by Steen on 11-02-03 at 05:58 PM
Osten
"Ryan S."
Posted by I_AM_HE on 11-02-03 at 06:01 PM
was the best choice for Morgan at that time. he was the biggest liability

"Osten"
Posted by tribephyl on 11-02-03 at 06:39 PM
Yea!

S7 What if? ...

Now is our opportunity, for revenge on MB.
He did mention that we, as "internet junkies", weren't normal, I beleive he is right. Let's see exactly how right he is.


Unfortunately, for Osten, he doesn't last 3 days.
On day 2 he hitches a ride from a passing fishing boat and takes the next flight home.
So is my wish! So shall be my vote!

Bye Osten. I hardly miss thee.

NEXT IC: Morgan wins.


tribephyl

"RYAN S"
Posted by bobstew617 on 11-02-03 at 08:31 PM
LAST EDITED ON 11-02-03 AT 08:32 PM (EST)

OOOOH! Thanks, IE, for starting this thread! I've been in "what-if" withdrawal. Maybe BaquaR13 will reappear for this..haven't seen him(?) on the boards in a while.

"Skinny Ryan" would have been gone if Nicole hadn't screwed up in Ep1 and Osten hadn't yet shown signs of wanting to quit at this point. (Don't worry..I can't wait to see him gone out of this game, too!!)

Next IC winner: DRAKE

What will we do with the twist?

"Osten"
Posted by coolflowerpowerman on 11-02-03 at 09:46 PM
Osten is and always was worthless!
"Assuming..."
Posted by Goooey_Alley on 11-03-03 at 01:12 AM
- Nicole shut her mouth, Ryan S. and Lill will be the 1st two boots, and Andrew might be the 3rd one to go (with a strong bond between Tijuana and Darrah while stringing Ryan O, Osten, and Nicole).

- Drake didn't throw the 4th IC, the 4th boot will be Osten for quitting, leaving a 4 advantage for Drake.

- Burton thinks more strategically knowing they had a 4 advantage rather than 3, they threw the 5th IC booting Jon because Sandra leaked the vote-switching of Jon to Michelle-Burton. Leaving Shawn an odd-man.

- No kidnapping happened, nothing happened to envy Rupert's popularity. They decided to throw another challenge. Since Shawn is a weasel and might change alliance in merge, he is booted.

- No OUTCAST tribe exixts, Drake won its IC. Nicole couldn't handle her mouth, she expressed her anger with Tijuana, she is the next one out.

Now we are left with:

DRAKES: Rupert, Christa, Sandra, Trish (4-member alliance with Trish being a weak ally) Michelle, Burton (2-member strong alliance that might jump ship)

MORGANS: Darrah, Tijuana, Ryan O. (3-member-strong alliance)

... and this might be a Marquesas-look-a-like-situation season.

"Nicole"
Posted by echogirl on 11-03-03 at 05:21 AM
LAST EDITED ON 11-03-03 AT 05:23 AM (EST)

I wanted to go Osten but since he didn't want to quit until E2, Nicole is the obvious boot. Next week I pick Osten!

Drake wins IC.

"Suggestion"
Posted by echogirl on 11-03-03 at 05:25 AM
Hey IE!

These "What If" games are a blast, but I suggest no vote changes.

"Great Suggestion"
Posted by JohnMc on 11-05-03 at 05:58 PM
I agree w/the red ink queen. No vote changes.
"RE: Great Suggestion"
Posted by I_AM_HE on 11-05-03 at 06:02 PM
make this a third vote for no vote changes
"Nicole"
Posted by Kokoro on 11-03-03 at 10:52 AM
Oh my heck! We haven't had one of these in such a long time!

Anyway, Nicole sucked at the game and she's hugely blah. It's time for her to go.

IC: The Drake

"Osten"
Posted by DEVILRAYS on 11-03-03 at 11:50 AM
Don't care if he didn't throw in the towel until next week; this vote is simply to correct an MB casting error.
"Osten"
Posted by Nash on 11-03-03 at 11:59 AM
Drake wins IC

Osten is a whining baby. Who else but Osten?

"RE: Survivor 7 What if?"
Posted by silentJ on 11-03-03 at 06:22 PM
Nicole made the first mistake, she deserved to go first.
I vote Nicole (wow, the Morgans actually made a good decision?)
Drake wins next IC

"OSTEN"
Posted by Acawap on 11-03-03 at 06:37 PM
I vote him out Round 1, Round 2, Round 3, Round 4 and Round 5, don't care if Morgan wins immunity or not.

Hard to say Nicole sucked at the game when she was only around for like an hour our time. She tried to play the game just like everybody else, but she made the mistake of playing her cards too early. Stupid, granted, but I keep her around at least long enough to see what happens to that blue dress come water challenges ;)

Osten sucks, and I'd put his name on the parchment every TC, whether he was still on the tribe or not. If Drake went to TC, I'd storm in just to write his name down again. Can't stand that whiny, lazy, narcissistic, body-temple talkin' about good-for-nuttin' LOSER... but I digress into Bashers

"Survivor 7 What if? Round 2"
Posted by ivoryElephant on 11-04-03 at 12:49 PM
Although he didn't start whining until ep. 2 it was a blowout as the first person to be voted out is...


Osten

Final Words: Well, I guess I just wasn't prepared to take on the elementsof my backyard much less Panama.

(photochop courtesy of Chrissy Gal)

The winner of The IC is DRAKE

Morgan heads to TC to vote off yet another castaway

Morgan

Ryan S.
Ryan O.
Andrew S.
Nicole
Tijuana
Darrah
Lillian



"Nicole"
Posted by Kokoro on 11-04-03 at 04:02 PM
She's done nothing to show she should stay any longer.

IC: The Drake

"Nicole"
Posted by tribephyl on 11-04-03 at 04:20 PM
No real reason to keep her around any longer.

IC:Morgan

tribephyl

"Nicole"
Posted by bobstew617 on 11-04-03 at 10:02 PM
LAST EDITED ON 11-04-03 AT 10:04 PM (EST)

Her mouth would have gotten her in trouble eventually, and it keeps the tribe balanced by gender. (IE, those pansies are classic! Osten fits in so well with them )

Next IC: MORGAN (Edited for IC winner)

"RE: Nicole"
Posted by bubbastan on 11-05-03 at 01:12 AM
It was clear from her own confessional that she couldn't keep her mouth shut if someone annoyed her. That sort of behavior coupled with premature plotting always spells an early exit.
IC: Drake
"Ryan S."
Posted by I_AM_HE on 11-05-03 at 06:12 PM
i'm certainly not sad to see osten go, but geekboy was, and still is, the proper choice
"Nicole"
Posted by Blow by Blow on 11-05-03 at 06:17 PM
You just know she'd keep plotting against Tijuana and would get the boot this week. But let me add, if Osten had gotten the boot in Ep1, then Morgan might have actually been able to win IC in Ep2.

That picture of Osten with the pansies - very funny. But I don't think Osten would be smiling if he was surrounded by giant flowers. He'd be griping about terminal allergies and sharpening his machete.

-P

"Andrew"
Posted by coolflowerpowerman on 11-08-03 at 04:24 PM
Bye-bye, Andrew!
" Osten"
Posted by ryan_from_canada on 11-04-03 at 01:06 PM
Round 1, definitely Osten. Why wait till round 2 to see him whine?

Drake wins next IC.

"Ryan S. "
Posted by LozengeofLove on 11-04-03 at 03:24 PM
As much as I liked him, he was never a physical asset to the tribe.
The next IC would be ANdrew v. Rupert, so once again, Drake wins.
"OSTEN"
Posted by johnthemod on 11-04-03 at 05:53 PM
Really, most of Morgan could go at this point for all I care, with the exception of Ryan O. But I didn't like Osten from day one, before he even started in with the quitting, so my vote goes for him.

IC: Drake

"Nicole"
Posted by JohnMc on 11-05-03 at 05:56 PM
My inclination is to get rid of Wussten, but we really didn't know he'd be a wuss until the next Morgan boot. She did screw up first, before Wussten did.

History could not change Nicole quite foolishly trying to boot off T instead of going w/the tribe and getting rid of Skinny Ryan or Lil first.

But believe you me, when Wussten asks for the boot this time, I'm gonna give it to him!

"Rnd 2 Results. Round 3 Tribal Counsel"
Posted by ivoryElephant on 11-05-03 at 11:11 PM
In a gut wrenching second TC for the Morgan tribe the next person voted out is.....


NICOLE

Final Words: "I just couldn't keep my mouth shut, ya know whenever there is food around I just can't shut it, so I got voted out for eating my own words when it came down to it"


The winners of the third Immunity Challenge are the Drake Tribe

Thus Morgan goes to TC for the 3rd time in a row

Vote for one of the following

Ryan S.
Ryan O.
Andrew S.
Tijuana
Darrah
Lillian



"RE: Rnd 2 Results. Round 3 Tribal Counsel"
Posted by ejm92 on 11-06-03 at 01:08 AM
Darrah. We hardly know ye.


Survior 5 Anti-Bootee Champ, Survivor 6 Anti-Bootee Chump
"Darrah "
Posted by LozengeofLove on 11-06-03 at 01:38 AM
Just leave. If it's still (somehow) you v. Lill -- you deserve to go.
Morgan wins the next tribal council!
"Ryan S."
Posted by tribephyl on 11-06-03 at 06:07 AM
Icky
"Darrah"
Posted by Kokoro on 11-06-03 at 09:35 AM
Why is the brainless bimbo always a prime casting choice every single season?

IC: Morgan

"Osten .... still"
Posted by Acawap on 11-06-03 at 12:01 PM
don't care if he's already gone. He's still gets my vote.

"RyanS"
Posted by Blow by Blow on 11-06-03 at 12:58 PM
'cause Darrah's 80% is still way more than RyanS's 110% while Lill's campsite work ethic starts to pay. And here's how I score them:

Looks: Darrah
Personality: None
Screen presence: None
Athleticism: Darrah

So, a close challenge, but Darrah comes out ahead of both Lill and RyanS.

"RYAN S."
Posted by johnthemod on 11-06-03 at 01:02 PM
I just don't really see any reason to keep him around.

IC: Drake Tribe

"Ryan Shoulders"
Posted by ivoryElephant on 11-06-03 at 05:15 PM
Boot: Ryan S

IC DRAKE


"Ryan S."
Posted by ryan_from_canada on 11-06-03 at 07:37 PM
Not much to offer, so now's the time.... Ciao Ryan.
"Darrah"
Posted by bobstew617 on 11-06-03 at 10:07 PM
LAST EDITED ON 11-06-03 AT 10:11 PM (EST)

She would have been gone if Lil wasn't voted out this round...

IC: MORGAN

Acawap: we get your point about osten--he is out of the game. STOP IT.

"Darrah"
Posted by bubbastan on 11-07-03 at 00:37 AM
Ahhhhh, what can I say, there's just something about Geekboy that I find rather oddly appealing. Though Darrah has done pretty well in some challenges, she doesn't add much to the day to day camp activities and has had pretty much zero presence on the show overall.
"Andrew"
Posted by djandy on 11-07-03 at 10:05 AM
Morgan wouldn't be so pathetic if they didn't have Andrew as a leader.

IC: Morgan (So I can vote out Jon next)

djandy

"RE: Rnd 2 Results. Round 3 Tribal Counsel"
Posted by Nash on 11-07-03 at 10:20 AM
osten osten
"Osten"
Posted by JohnMc on 11-07-03 at 12:26 PM
You want us to vote you out because your week. We have the foresight to know that if you stay, you will be a detriment to the tribe. You only look strong, but your heart is not with this game. You are weak, and if we continue with us, you will only drag us down. Our hope to be a unified tribe lies with voting out the weak and keeping the strong.

Skinny Ryan is stronger than you. He has 110% heart, where you have none. I will not vote for Ryan S; for the strength and positive future of our tribe, I will vote for Osten.

OSTEN HATERS UNITE TO VOTE HIM OFF NOW - IT IS HIS TURN

"geekboy"
Posted by I_AM_HE on 11-07-03 at 09:05 PM
third time's the charm. still think he was the weakest link and deserved to go.

darrah (or fat ryan) would also be a good choice

id we're picking immunity, i'll say drake DOESN'T throw the challenge and wins again.


"rnd 3 results Round 4 TC"
Posted by ivoryElephant on 11-08-03 at 01:54 PM
In a Very close round it came down to one vote for booting and for the IC

darrah
ryan s
darra
ryan s
darrah
ryan s
darrah
darrah
ryan
ryan

and the third person voted out of the game is...


Skinny Ryan!!!!!

And for the first time....

..
Morgan wins Immunity!!!

here is the rest of the Morgan tribe

Andrew
Ryan O.
Lillian
Darrah
Tijuana

Drake goes to TC

vote for one of the following

Rupert
Jon
Shawn
Burton
Sandra
Christa
Trish
Michelle


"JON!"
Posted by tribephyl on 11-08-03 at 04:03 PM
yehaw!

I've just been itchin' for this day to come.

It's a "Smackdown"

IC:
Morgan


tribephyl

"SHAWN"
Posted by coolflowerpowerman on 11-08-03 at 04:23 PM
Bye-bye!
"RE: rnd 3 results Round 4 TC"
Posted by Steen on 11-08-03 at 04:32 PM
I'll go with Jon. He's mostly useless, like shawn, but annoying too.

(Sorry about my last post. I was a little late)

"Shawn"
Posted by LozengeofLove on 11-08-03 at 04:37 PM
We need someone there for the drama. Jon can go next week.
Drake wins IC.
"Jonny Fairplay"
Posted by bobstew617 on 11-08-03 at 09:18 PM
For those of us who are REALLY playing this game...
I can't stand this guy--he needs to go NOW.

IC: DRAKE

"bye jon"
Posted by cqvenus on 11-09-03 at 12:41 PM
hate him. let's get rid of him now.

I want Morgan to win IC.


rooting for the underdog since 1978

"Jon!!"
Posted by bubbastan on 11-09-03 at 02:14 PM
Please, please, please, let it be so.
"Shawn"
Posted by Kokoro on 11-09-03 at 04:56 PM
The only Drake I genuinely dislike. And since it looks like he's not going this time....

IC: Morgan

"Jon"
Posted by JohnMc on 11-10-03 at 11:05 AM
I must vote off my namesake for the sake of all sane people... and because I can't vote for wussten.

Drake IC when Morgan throws the challenge to boot wussten.

"Andrew"
Posted by coolflowerpowerman on 11-08-03 at 04:25 PM
LAST EDITED ON 11-08-03 AT 04:25 PM (EST)

Never mind!

"RE: Rnd 2 Results. Round 3 Tribal Counsel"
Posted by Steen on 11-08-03 at 04:31 PM
Lil


Awesome J Slice Creation 2003

"RE: Rnd 2 Results. Round 3 Tribal Counsel"
Posted by ivoryElephant on 11-10-03 at 02:13 PM
Boot: Jonny fairplay

IC: Drake

"Rnd 4 results, Rnd 5 TC"
Posted by ivoryElephant on 11-10-03 at 02:16 PM
in a 7-3 vote Jonnypainintheass has been voted out of the tribe

The winner of the IC is Drake

Morgan goes to TC once again...

Vote out one of the following

Andrew
Ryan O.
Darrah
Tijuana
Lillian



"Lillian"
Posted by silentJ on 11-10-03 at 02:40 PM
I wouldn't vote for her, but, the knuckleheads will stick together.

Ep 6 IC is the pole thing. Drake has 3 strong men, Morgan has two. Drake wins immunity.

"ANDREW!"
Posted by djandy on 11-10-03 at 03:10 PM
Who couldn't lead his tribe down a paved path.

IC: Morgan

djandy

"Lil"
Posted by JohnMc on 11-10-03 at 04:10 PM
But can we get some clarification, because I am totally confused.

First off, can we get a summary of who has been booted, who is still in, as well as who is up to be voted on in the What If? game?

Second, how much time takes place in between TC's? They seem to be happening so fast that I can't even keep up.


Besides, if I had realized that wussten had been voted out during the first round, I wouldn't have voted for him later nor foolishly organized the Boot Wussten campaign. I'd have also voted some other people off differently as well as picking different IC picks.

"RE: Rnd 4 results, Rnd 5 TC"
Posted by coolflowerpowerman on 11-10-03 at 04:24 PM
LAST EDITED ON 11-10-03 AT 09:55 PM (EST)

Andrew
Andrew
Andrew!

IC: Drake

"Andrew"
Posted by tribephyl on 11-10-03 at 04:51 PM
IC:Morgan


tribephyl

"Lillian"
Posted by bubbastan on 11-10-03 at 06:34 PM
Not really liking Lil all that much since she's been back. That being said, I still would have voted for Darrah, but would have been wasting my vote. So, it's Lil this time around.

IC: Drake

"Andrew"
Posted by bobstew617 on 11-10-03 at 10:25 PM
LAST EDITED ON 11-11-03 AT 11:07 PM (EST)

Because this time, he couldn't hold his weight...

For the twist: DRAKE wins, OUTCASTS 2nd, MORGAN last

(I do admit this game is going a little fast...)

"Lillian"
Posted by LozengeofLove on 11-10-03 at 10:36 PM
LAST EDITED ON 11-11-03 AT 02:03 AM (EST)

Stop pouting. Get on with your life.
Drake wins IC again.

"summary of events so far"
Posted by ivoryElephant on 11-11-03 at 01:42 PM
I will try and clear it up and will not tally the votes as quickly, here is what has happened so far.

outcasts
Osten
nicole
ryan s.
Jon

Morgan
andrew
lillian
tijuana
ryan o.
darrah
(andrew and lillian currently on the chopping block this round)

Drake
rupert
burton
shawn
sandra
michelle
trish
christa


For the Immunity challenge on the twist you get to decide what order the three teams finish.

So your vote may look something like this:

IC:
1st drake
2nd outcast
3rd morgan

so there may or may not be anyone voted back into the game


"Andrew"
Posted by ejm92 on 11-12-03 at 08:22 AM
I don't like Andrew.

IC:
1. Drake
2. Morgan
3. Outcasts


Survior 5 Anti-Bootee Champ, Survivor 6 Anti-Bootee Chump
"RE: Rnd 4 results, Rnd 5 TC"
Posted by Steen on 11-11-03 at 02:05 PM
Lil
"Andrew"
Posted by Kokoro on 11-12-03 at 00:35 AM
I'd rather it be Sarrah, but that's not the way this one is going.

IC: Drake

Also: 1.) Outcasts, 2.) Morgan, 3.) Drake

"kokoro, ejm...."
Posted by ivoryElephant on 11-12-03 at 12:04 PM
sorry, I haven't done the twist yet, I was just letting everyone know in advance. |I can still keep your picks in mind. The twist will come after 6 people are voted off
"RE: kokoro, ejm...."
Posted by ivoryElephant on 11-12-03 at 05:00 PM
Vote: Andrew

IC: Drake


current tally

andrew 7
lill 5


keep those votes coming