He definitely made S3 at least more watchable, he was good at challenges, and would stir up the pot. I'll nominate him "just in case".

This will probably make a couple ppl mad lol

But I want my girl Vee in the game

Could have picked a few different people but I thought he had the best chance of my favorites. Go Gervase!

The Cubs win the World Series!Cubbies Win!Cubbies Win!

But I'm sure everyone knew that he would be my nomination

>>>But I'm sure everyone knew that he would be my nomination<<<

Hey, you can't fault someone for going with their favourites

(Another IceCat original )

The Top 5 FLL Castaways

1. Neleh Dennis (11 weeks at #1)
2. Colby Donaldson (5 weeks at #1)
3. Amber Brkich (4 weeks at #1)
3. Lex Van Den Burghe (4 weeks at #1)
5. Elisabeth Filarski (3 weeks at #1)
5. Helen Glover (3 weeks at #1)
5. Kim Powers (3 weeks at #1)

Had to get it close to the other SR posting!

2002 IceCat Originals, Inc. All rights reserved.

He's gay, he's from Dallas, he's hot I just gotta pick him.

Come in a stranger,leave a little stranger

GASPPPP...... I can't believe I beat ivory to this!

Kathy O'Brien... The Sole Survivor! (I'd rather be delusional)

Whoo I think I made it ^-^;;

-----------------------------------
Now let us never speak of S3 again.

LAST EDITED ON 11-24-02 AT 09:59 PM (EST)

Neleh, Helen, Elisabeth, Vecepia, Kathy, Colleen
Lex, Gervase, Sean R., Brandon, Rudy

If this works out, we actually have a pretty good and diverse cast so far (as in they're not all twenty something ;)....3 more men and 2 more women to go.

-----------------------------------
Now let us never speak of S3 again.

I agree Kokoro..So Far the cast looks pretty good!

I'll nominate Jake (S5)......do you guys think we'll be better off going with the nomination game, or possibly doing two separate games?

I think it would be cool to do both because they are both equally great games. Plus it would be fair for the people who voted for their tribe of eight. (Plus I wanna play both )

But then again I wont be running the games, so its up to you

Well, both can be done then....we'll commence with the tribe of eight, and if anyone wants to do the nomination thing right now, they can, if not, I'll get it started later on, but we have a lot of games running now.

Damn

I really wanted to do the nomination game instead..cuz we had some awesome nominees for the game..but it is your call ejm

And I would do the nomination game if you didn't want too..but I gotta host the Survivor What If? Marquesas Edition first...Which should be starting some time late next week cuz the original survivor game is almost over!

BMH, would you mind if I ran the nomination game? I would really appreciate getting to run one

(Another IceCat original )

The Top 5 FLL Castaways

1. Neleh Dennis (11 weeks at #1)
2. Colby Donaldson (5 weeks at #1)
3. Amber Brkich (4 weeks at #1)
3. Lex Van Den Burghe (4 weeks at #1)
5. Elisabeth Filarski (3 weeks at #1)
5. Helen Glover (3 weeks at #1)
5. Kim Powers (3 weeks at #1)

Sure!

It would actually help me and Ejm out..Ejm could run the 8-player pick style game..and you can run the nomination game

And then we would have me hosting the Marquesas version and we already have Ejm and Baquar hostin S2 and S3

I mean the sooner we can play the game the better..because I must say the nominees thus far..are really good..we have a really diverse group of people..And with the S1 game coming to an end..It would really not be an overflow of games..

Thanks for helping out..you didn't even have to ask!

PS:You should probably plan on starting the game some time next week..Cuz We should at least wait until the S1 game is officially over..and of course that you have all 16 nominees ok

In the nomination game, when your survivor gets voted out, does that mean you lose as well and have to leave the game? Because thats pretty awesome and I like that idea. But if not thats ok too.

>>>In the nomination game, when your survivor gets voted out, does that mean you lose as well and have to leave the game?<<<

Absolutely not, oko! In fact, I'm afraid that if we did end up running the nomination game like that, we'd get too close to what a site called SurvivorSucks did when they voted people off their boards. Many feelings were hurt and we really don't need that here. So, because it's a little nicer, I'm gonna say no kicking people out of the game in nomination. Hope that's alright with everyone

<breaks a Kola nut with oko >

(Another IceCat original )

The Top 5 FLL Castaways

1. Neleh Dennis (11 weeks at #1)
2. Colby Donaldson (5 weeks at #1)
3. Amber Brkich (4 weeks at #1)
3. Lex Van Den Burghe (4 weeks at #1)
5. Elisabeth Filarski (3 weeks at #1)
5. Helen Glover (3 weeks at #1)
5. Kim Powers (3 weeks at #1)

Sounds perfect. I'll get the 8-player tribes started sometime next week, Erist can do the nomination, and BMH can begin Survivor 4.....anyone interested in a Big Brother? I doubt we have enough people alert of those boards to do one until BB4 starts up, though. If there is an opening slot to do Survivor 5 What If?, lol, I'd love to.

LAST EDITED ON 11-26-02 AT 09:36 PM (EST)

A big Brother What If? Game would be cool...but your right there really wouldn't be enough people to vote..cuz that board has been dead ever since the show ended unfortunately..I was a huge BB3 fan..but did not bost at The BB message boards here..i posted at the Tv clubhouse however..A What If? would still be cool

EDIT~Oh and yes of course..you are more than welcome to host Survivor 5 What If..because no-one else has volunteered..unless..you wanna get Baquar to do it..when he is done with Survivor 3..Cuz you are gonna run the 8-player game..But it is all up to you if you want it

If Baquar wants to take it, he can, but since the offseason is coming and stuff like spoilers will be dead, I'll have plenty of time.

Ok Well it is up to you..because I don't want it to be a hassle to run 2 games..and Whoever does end up hostin S5 won't do it right away anyways..I mean S2 and S3 aren't even half over yet, and we already got the S4,8-ppl,and nomination game in the works..no need to rush S5.

Just a thought, maybe we could tuck S4, S5 and S6 away for next season. It'd be especially cool to do S6 as the season progresses, and it'd be more exciting since we don't know how the challenges would turn out, who we won't like, etc. That would be wicked fun IMO

(Another IceCat original )

The Top 5 FLL Castaways

1. Neleh Dennis (11 weeks at #1)
2. Colby Donaldson (5 weeks at #1)
3. Amber Brkich (4 weeks at #1)
3. Lex Van Den Burghe (4 weeks at #1)
5. Elisabeth Filarski (3 weeks at #1)
5. Helen Glover (3 weeks at #1)
5. Kim Powers (3 weeks at #1)

I was just thinking about having S6 during it's run that would be fun!!

But I really wanted to do S4 What If? cuz I wouldn't have anything to do..now that S1 is almost over lol

Neleh, Helen, Elisabeth, Vecepia, Kathy, Colleen
Lex, Gervase, Sean R., Brandon, Rudy, Jake, Rodger

We need 2 more women and one more man....maybe you should repost this in a new thread Erist.

-----------------------------------
Now let us never speak of S3 again.

Didn't see the first Survivor, so I can't fairly choose from that group. I chose 2 from every other season. Not necessarily favorites, but people who would keep the pot stirred.

Jeff V, Alicia, Lex, T-bird, Rob M, Tammy, Shii Ann, Ken

Cool!!! Ok...

- Kelly G
- Penny (top two are the fiesty ones)
- Teresa
- Neleh (you two are the sweet ones)
- Colby
- Keith
- Lex
- Brian

What? Only 8? Gotta go with:
Kathy, Teresa, Shii Ann, Tanya (gotta have 1 sweetheart and she's my fave sweetheart)
Richard (it wouldn't be Ultimate Survivor without Rich), Jeff, Lex, Hunter (I want my eye candy)

Kathy O'Brien... The Sole Survivor! (I'd rather be delusional)

I wouldn't call this my dream team; more like "If I Was On Survivor, Who Would I Want To Hang Out With" team . Some were my favorites, and then I picked based on entertainment purposes, good or bad.

Gervase
Brandon
Jeff
Jake
Alicia
Kathy
Gretchen
Sue

My alternates - I took Rudy off and replaced him with Jake, as I thought I had too many from S1. And if I could pick an alternate woman, it would be Jerri *cringe*, but just to see her get kicked off AGAIN .

Jeff Varner
Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien
Helen Glover
Tanya Vance
Jessie Camacho
Greg Buis
Colby Donaldson
Rodger Bingham

Off the top of my head. Once I post it, I will not allow myself to change my mind.

My dream team should be called "team sweetheart"

Colleen, Elizabeth, Alicia, Kim Powers, Gabe, Gina, Stephanie, Colby

Rich
Sue
Colleen
Greg
Colby
Jeff V.
Elisabeth
Robb

I didn't include anyone I consider "evil," since it is our ultimate team. 8 is very difficult! With 16, I could have included a couple people I "love to hate."

Sticking with 4/4 and automatically eliminating winners: Mixing brain, some physical ability, and interestingness (except for Jake, who is included as token oldie guy).

Sean Rector
Jake
Brandon
Jeff Varner
Kathy
Kelly W.
Shii Ann
Alicia

My Dream tribe--Ramona,Joel,Jerri,Jeff,Jessie,Clarence,Vecepia,and Rob Mariano

And If you are gonna do that nominate thing

I nominate Rob Mariano!!!

LAST EDITED ON 11-28-02 AT 06:08 AM (EST)

Colleen, Alicia, Teresa, Kathy, Rudy, Colby, Lex, Jake

-----------------------------------
Now let us never speak of S3 again.

Okay can the voting be over now? I have a good way to tally here....I have all the voting data and here's my idea:

We take the three top vote getters from each season. Right now our cast is:

S1: Rudy, Colleen, Susan
S2: Elisabeth, Colby, Jeff
S3: Lex, Brandon, Teresa
S4: Kathy, Rob, Sean
S5: Shii Ann, Helen, Jake

That gives us 15 and we need one more....so we take the 4th top vote getter from each season and now we can vote on the wildcard:

S1: Gervase
S2: Alicia
S3: Ethan
S4: Gina
S5: Clay/Robb

If we're going to be specific, we need a woman and it could be narrowed down to just Alicia and Gina but it might be more fun to vote with all five seasons involved.

-----------------------------------
Now let us never speak of S3 again.

I say we have a vote off between Gina and Alicia.

I vote for Gina to make it.

"I got a kiss from Clay Jordan, oh my god am I queen for a day" - Helen Glover

No offense kokoro, but isnt this a little complicated?

Why dont you just take the 8 females with the most votes and the 8 males with the most votes? Thats a lot simpiler and probably more fair because there are seasons that probably got more votes so it would be harder for a castmember to get in because it would be more cutthroat.

What would the cast be if it was just the top 8 females and top 8 males?

Females: Kathy, Elisabeth, Colleen, Susan, Alicia, Shii Ann

Teresa, Jerri, Helen

Males:

Colby, Rudy, Jeff, Lex, Rodger, Brandon, Rob

Jake, Sean

The names underneath require additional vote-offs so basically, you can see that it's even further complicated and a far less diverse crowd if we go with only the top 8.

-----------------------------------
Now let us never speak of S3 again.

Happy thanksgiving to all!!

Can I pick 8 ppl still?...or is it too late??

Oh well..here are my eight:

Sean K,Gretchen,Jerri,Colby,Tom,Lindsey,Vecepia,Rob M

LAST EDITED ON 11-30-02 AT 09:59 PM (EST)

S1: Rudy, Colleen, Susan
S2: Elisabeth, Colby, Jeff
S3: Lex, Brandon, Teresa
S4: Kathy, Rob, Sean
S5: Shii Ann, Helen, Jake

I totally agree with Kokoro's original idea, three from each season and one wild card. Mark Burnett is planning on doing his all-star edition with a predetermined number of contestants from each season to prevent extra alliances, and since a lot of people either didn't watch Survivor 1 or don't care for Survivor 3 or 5, I think it'll be more fair that way. As for our last nominee, I am just going to throw some names around, but I will take the first ten votes and then determine who is the last cast member...I'll just add some of the better characters from each season that didn't get in, but if you have a better idea, vote for someone else.....

S1 - Kelly W, Gretchen, Jenna
S2 - Alicia, Jerri, Tina
S3 - Kim J., Kim P., Jessie
S4 - Vee, Neleh
S5 - Erin, Tanya, Penny, Jan

Vote for ONE WOMAN from EACH season. The player with the most nominations gets in, and as I said, I'll take the first ten posts.

S1 - Kelly W.
S2 - Tina
S3 - Kim J.
S4 - Neleh
S5 - Jan

how does this game work? There are so many

Oh well I will vote anyways

s1 jenna
s2 jerri
s3 kim p
s4 vee
s5 tanya

Once we get the last player, I'll divvy them up into tribes and then we can vote like the other "What if?" games.

Looks like we aren't going to get a tenth vote anytime soon, so I'll cut it off at nine, since Vee ran away with it and basically would've won with another vote....VEE is the sixteenth cast member, and I'll begin the show later tonight in a new thread.

S1~Jenna
S2~Jerri
S3~Jessie
S4~Vee
S5~Penny

Here are my picks for the last spot:

S1: Gretchen
S2: Alicia
S3: Jessie
S4: Neleh
s5: Jan

S1--Jenna
S2--Jerri..Go Jerri!
S3--Kim P.
S4--Vecepia..Go Vee!
S5--Penny

LAST EDITED ON 12-01-02 AT 01:35 AM (EST)

S1 - Jenna
S2 - Tina
S3 - Kim P.
S4 - Neleh (I would rather vote for Gina, but i am not.)
S5 - Erin

S1 - Kelly W
S2 - Alicia
S3 - Jessie
S4 - Vee
S5 - Jan

S1: Kelly W
S2: Alicia
S3: Jessie (I wanna see who she's really like)
S4: Neither Vee or Neleh but if I have to choose, Vee (same reason as above)
S5: Tanya (same reasoning again as Jessie and Vee)

Kathy O'Brien... The Sole Survivor! (I'd rather be delusional)

S1 - Kelly W.
S2 - Tina
S3 - Jessie
S4 - Vee (only because winners should be in "All Star" versions)
S5 - Jan

-----------------------------------
Now let us never speak of S3 again.

LAST EDITED ON 12-01-02 AT 09:23 PM (EST)

S1: Kelly W.
S2: Amber
S3: Lindsey
S4: Sarah
S5: Erin

Edited to say...oops late.

T-Mac hits the three! Magic Win! Magic Win!

That'll be the tenth vote....I messed up and put the post in the wrong place, anyways, Vecepia is the last cast member, and I'll start the new thread later tonight once I divvy up the tribes.

2002 NFC North Champs