URL: http://community.realitytvworld.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/rtvw2/community/dcboard.cgi
Forum: DCForumID17
Thread Number: 1839
[ Go back to previous page ]
Original Message
"Power of 10"
Posted by emydi on 08-08-07 at 10:11 AM
http://www.cbs.com/primetime/powerof10/
I like it. A 19 year old won a million dollars last nite!!
Drew Carey was good http://community.tvguide.com/blog-entry/TVGuide-Editors-Blog/Roush-Dispatch/Drew-Power/800020032
Although imo it was nice to watch it on DVR (like Singing bee and Don't forget lyrics too) to ff thru a bit too much banter from Drew..Although he is a good host he just rambles on too much.
Another one tonite. I really thought more women would think they are feminists...answer 29%
Table of contents
- RE: Power of 10,Estee, 10:24 AM, 08-08-07
- RE: Power of 10,emydi, 11:12 AM, 08-08-07
- RE: Power of 10,Fishercat, 06:10 PM, 08-08-07
- RE: Power of 10,dragonflies, 09:09 AM, 08-10-07
- RE: Power of 10,Hoobie, 02:25 AM, 09-15-07
- RE: Power of 10,Snidget, 07:50 AM, 09-15-07
- RE: Power of 10,Agman2, 11:40 AM, 02-26-16
- RE: Power of 10,Agman2, 03:47 PM, 02-18-16
- RE: Power of 10,kidflash212, 01:49 PM, 07-10-16
Messages in this discussion
"RE: Power of 10"
Posted by Estee on 08-08-07 at 10:24 AM
The game requires more thought than most of the crop to come along in the last few years: that's a plus right there. Not too much thought, and it's definitely possible to overthink the questions -- but at least the blind picking is mostly off the board.Right now, it feels like it's too easy to reach the million. Sure, the shrinking range is a decent touch, and having a ten percent margin of error on the final question is going to limit a lot of guesses -- but at the same time, there are going to be questions where your answer range is down to a pretty small possibility anyway, and what you've got to work with is more than enough to use. Having the audience register their opinion on the first four questions is too much of a help: it's like having a lifeline active at virtually all times.
At the same time, it's hard to see anyone going for the ten million. Just about a nine percent chance of making it? No thank you: I'm not going for that without a hefty dose of clairvoyance or personally knowing everyone who took the poll... I predict we'll see some more million-and-drop contestants, but it'll be a long time before anyone shoots the moon.
Pacing isn't bad, and that's even with very few questions asked during the premiere. Maybe that's because the between-answers talk is actually about something. And let's face it: you can do a lot worse than debating about how many people felt VP Cheney would be able to kill them in a duel.
Drew -- as the review says, this doesn't reflect any ability he might have to host TPIR, especially as regards pacing. He's good with contestant interaction, he needs to stop repeating some of his jokes, and it'll take an episode or two before his laugh either stops being a little annoying or becomes really irritating. But he was actually funny a couple of times last night, and he just seemed to fit the show -- at least for now.
Honestly, what this reminded me of more than anything else was Family Feud. Survey says...
"RE: Power of 10"
Posted by emydi on 08-08-07 at 11:12 AM
I said that myself too last night, the only difference is that there were multiple answers in FFI like it a lot...I really thought Drew was sincere (but who knows he did say the producers weren't expecting it) when he told the kid not to go for it unless he was sure. I wouldn't have gone for it (but I thought the answer was in the 50% range)--so good for him. And I definitely don't think anyone will go for the 10 million...like you said, you'd have to know everyone that did the survey. A guaranteed million can help to change your life, 100K can pay some bills...so who would be stupid enough to try...only one to do that wd be acomp gambler imho
I agree there are too many life lines. It should be 1 of each --- one going to family/friend and one ask the audience.
I'm going to keep watching this
"RE: Power of 10"
Posted by Fishercat on 08-08-07 at 06:10 PM
Good show, better than most of the Game Show crop (I'd put it behind 1 v. 100 and maybe Don't Forget The Lyrics, but those are the only two I can think of for current, primetime Game Shows), I'll keep watching. And I'll note, I was within about 5% of everything the 19-year old picked last night. I would have lost to him in the first round, but I would have been closer to the middle in the second round than he was. Weird stuff.
The feminist question was a little surprising to me too. I would have gotten the range right or at least very close, but I was personally thinking it would have been more, maybe 35.
The Cheney question was an easy guesser, I would have put it at 50% flat. The first one was a gimme.
But this show will get very tough and I don't think the million dollar prize will be that common. I see a LOT of 100,000 dollar prizes (that is a level to where 9,000 difference is worth risking for 90,000 more. When you have to risk 90,000, that's tough. Essentially the difference between a semester in a public college (10k) and a few years in college (100k) or an okay car and a really nice car.
I would have stopped at 100k though, absolutely.
"RE: Power of 10"
Posted by dragonflies on 08-10-07 at 09:09 AM
I'll keep watching for now too. About the feminist question, I was very close to correct, at 27%. DH suggested that while I am a textbook feminist, I don't consider myself one, in comparison to the bra burners of the 60s & 70s.
I think Drew made some very insightful comments, and if the contestants want to win, they should listen to him a little closer, for now. Although he needs to stop babbling quite so much.

It's a Sharnina siggie!
"RE: Power of 10"
Posted by Hoobie on 09-15-07 at 02:25 AM
These questions are just so random. What I mean by that is, the contestant has absolutely no knowledge whatsoever about how survey respondents feel.I'd really be interested in finding out who "America" is that was being polled. I know that I wasn't 
Whatever "random" sampling occurred, are the different questions being asked to the same group? Or different groups each time? How many individuals make up the sample size to be representative of America.
If anyone has any information on this...I truly want to know.
"RE: Power of 10"
Posted by Snidget on 09-15-07 at 07:50 AM
LAST EDITED ON 09-15-07 AT 07:51 AM (EST)From their website http://www.cbs.com/primetime/powerof10/community/
"Specific survey questions are determined by Power of 10 and submitted to Rasmussen Reports. Respondents are selected on a completely random basis through a process designed to insure an appropriate geographic distribution throughout the country. The reported results reflect the overall United States population in terms of age, race, gender, political party, and other factors."
No survey of any kind ever surveys every person they are trying to find out about. There are statistical techniques you use to determine how big a sample size you need to get a particular level of accuracy (and I don't know if they have ever stated which margin of error they are going for, to get within 5% of the number you would get if you could actually survey everyone is a much smaller sample size then to get within 1% of what you would get by surveying everyone).
The matching the group surveyed to the population as a whole you are trying to estimate is pretty standard. If you want to know what America as a whole thinks you want the sample group to be a mirror for what America as a whole looks like.

"RE: Power of 10"
Posted by Agman2 on 02-26-16 at 11:40 AM
Snidget, I agree with everything you said! I even like the fact you provided a link.(even though it no longer works)
"RE: Power of 10"
Posted by Agman2 on 02-18-16 at 03:47 PM
agman2 was here!
"RE: Power of 10"
Posted by kidflash212 on 07-10-16 at 01:49 PM
And gone.